Virginia Environmental News Roundup for November 2023

The Climate Action Alliance of the Valley is pleased to provide Harrisonburgโ€™s The Citizen with a monthly survey of energy and environmental news stories about Virginia.

With their permission, we are re-posting these pieces here after they appear in the Citizen.


The link to this piece as first published byย theย Citizenย isย HERE.

Statewide Environmental News Roundup for November 2023

Energy

Regulations and Utilities

โ€œA new report found Dominion Energyโ€™s Integrated Resource Plan does not align with Virginiaโ€™s climate goals. Dominion wants to keep using gas and coal-fired power plants, citing data center expansion in Northern Virginia but the Virginia Clean Economy Act mandated Dominion to use 100% renewable electricity by 2045. Dominionโ€™s plan does meet Gov. Glenn Youngkinโ€™s energy plan, which relies on both fossil fuels and renewables.โ€

โ€œPJM Interconnection staff โ€ฆ recommended about $4.9 billion in transmission projects to help address reliability concerns related to new data centers and power plant retirements in its footprint, according to a regional transmission expansion plan presentationโ€ฆ. Under the recommendations, Dominion Energy would build transmission projects totaling about $2.5 billionโ€ฆ.โ€ [See opinion pieces below.]

Dominion is replacing infrastructure to improve the electrical grid as part of the โ€œGrid Transformation Plan, which is being approved in chunks by state regulators. The GTP was required by state lawmakers in the 2018 Grid Transformation and Security Act. The plan seeks to make the electric grid more reliable and secure โ€“ and flexible for ever-growing distributed renewable energy sources. Regulators just approved Phase III of the plan in September, which runs from 2024 through 2026โ€ฆ. The plan has been criticized by ratepayer advocates and environmentalists over concerns with renewable planning and cost.โ€ The SCC has approved some aspects of Dominionโ€™s proposed grid infrastructure projects but not others.

Dominion and Rappahannock Electric Cooperative received federal grant money โ€œ$71.8 million from feds to improve power grid resiliency.โ€

Data Centers, Energy Storage

โ€œFollowing a public hearing โ€ฆ, the Spotsylvania Board of Supervisors approved rezoning from rural to industrial for a 127-acre tract โ€ฆ, with plans calling for data centers in an area surrounded mostly by trees and vacant property but also near several neighborhoods and the Spotsylvania Regional Medical Center.โ€

โ€œCiting a lack of information and numerous unanswered questions, Prince William Countyโ€™s professional planning staff is recommending denial on the Prince William Digital Gatewayโ€”one of the largest and most controversial commercial projects to come before the board of supervisors in decades.โ€ โ€œStaff rejected the applications largely because of the lack of information provided by developers. They pointed out that many of the documents submitted by the developers โ€˜contain technical errors, are contradictory, and contain nondescript verbiage โ€ฆ that may make enforcement of some of the proffers difficult.โ€™ Staff also determined the project is not in alignment with the countyโ€™s Comprehensive Plan, despite amendments made to the document last year to pave the way for the Digital Gateway.โ€ Subsequently, โ€œThe two developers behind the divisive PW Digital Gateway data center corridor โ€ฆ submitted amended project applications to Prince William County leaders in response to the countyโ€™s professional planning staff rejecting their initial plansโ€ฆ. [The] companies sought to assure officials they were committed to clarifying the imprecise information initially provided about the projectโ€™s layout and potential impacts on the surrounding area, which led county staff to pan the project.โ€ Subsequently, Following a 22-hour meeting on November 9th, Prince William Countyโ€™s Planning Commission โ€œrecommended the denial of all three rezoning applications associated with the divisive PW Digital Gateway data center proposal.โ€ โ€œBut that decision will not keep the project from moving forward to the board of supervisors for a possible vote on Dec. 12โ€ฆ.โ€

A new โ€œplant [in Southwest Virginia] will focus primarily on data center component manufacturing and containment products to serve customers in Virginia and other data center sites.โ€

Renewable Energy, Energy Efficiency, and Nuclear

What is, and isnโ€™t โ€œcleanโ€ energy? โ€œStates grappling to reach goals for renewables and emissions cuts from the power sector are finding a solution on paper: Rebrand what counts as โ€˜clean.โ€™ Thatโ€™s what North Carolina lawmakers did โ€ฆ when the stateโ€™s Republican supermajority overrode a veto from Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper, forcing through a law to rebrand nuclear as clean in the state energy mandate. Similar measures that symbolically or legally redefine natural gas and biomass as โ€œclean,โ€ โ€œgreenโ€ or โ€œrenewableโ€ also passed this year in Ohio, Tennessee and Virginia. While some energy rebranding has occurred for years, the recent action comes as states are increasingly being looked to help meet President Joe Bidenโ€™s goals to decarbonize the power sector by 2035.โ€

โ€œThe Interior Department approved the largest offshore wind project in the country โ€ฆ, marking the fifth massive wind array cleared for construction in U.S. oceans under [the current Administration]. The Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind project will include up to 176 turbines, located roughly 27 miles from Virginia Beach. The Dominion Energy-backed project will be the largest offshore wind project in the United States, able to zap enough electricity back to the grid once itโ€™s constructed in 2026 to power roughly 660,000 homesโ€ฆ.โ€ โ€œThe Biden Administration [also] announced that it will be providing over $39 million in funding for an offshore wind logistics facility in Norfolk.โ€

โ€œBut the Virginia project approval comes amid an economic storm for offshore wind, due to inflationary costs that threaten the 30-gigawatt targetRising prices to build offshore wind farms have threatened the viability of some of the first proposed projects in the country, off the coasts of New York, Connecticut, and Massachusettsโ€ฆ. (Two โ€œoffshore wind power projects in New Jersey [were recently scrapped because of] supply chain issues.โ€) Still the Virginia project represents a big step forward for the nascent industry and secures a footprint for offshore economic activity in the central Atlantic. The first four offshore wind projects approved in the United States โ€” two are under construction already off the coast of Massachusetts and Rhode Island โ€” are in New England.

The Virginia project is expected to create roughly 900 jobs a year during construction and support 1,100 jobs annually during operations, particularly in Virginiaโ€™s Hampton Roads coastal region.โ€ Dominion is seeking โ€œoutside investor interestโ€ in the project, notwithstanding the canceling of the New Jersey projects. โ€œA business model that allows Dominion Energy Inc. to be both a wind farm developer and a customer-facing utility is helping the company succeed in sharp contrast to others in the industry that are delaying or canceling US projects.โ€ Dominion said it lowered its โ€œcost estimates for powerโ€ โ€ฆ [for its wind project and] will decide by early 2024 whether or not to take on a partnerโ€ฆ.โ€ Virginiaโ€™s regulated monopoly utility model allows Dominion to recoup costs of such projects from ratepayers.

On the other hand, the project faces challenges. โ€œAmid failing turbine components and financial challenges, Siemens Gamesa Renewable Energy said [on November 10 that] it has โ€˜discontinuedโ€™ its plans to build the nationโ€™s first offshore wind-turbine blade manufacturing facility at the Port of Virginiaโ€™s Portsmouth Marine Terminal [because] โ€ฆ โ€˜development milestones to establish the facility could not be metโ€ฆ.โ€™โ€ Though long-term implications remain to be seen, Dominion said โ€œThis announcement has no impacts on our project.โ€ [See opinion pieces below.]

โ€œA new Occoquan Elementary School [in Prince William county] is set to completely replace the original 97-year-old building by 2026 and will be the countyโ€™s first โ€œnet-zeroโ€ school that produces as much energy as it consumes. Through solar panels and geothermal heating, the new school building will produce its own electricity and heat and will use half as much energy as a normal school building.โ€

โ€œSolar advocates in southwestern Virginia say being local, proving the technology works and building a coalition to support it have been keyโ€ to bringing solar to their region. โ€œIn 2016, a coalition of businesses, nonprofits, colleges, local governments, and citizens launched the Solar Workgroup of Southwest Virginia, which collaborates with Secure Solar Futures. It includes experts in every aspect of the green transition, from community organizers who tell neighbors about the benefits of solar to legal experts who propose legislation.โ€ [See opinion pieces below.]

โ€œIn August, the USDA announced $266 million distributed nationwide to โ€˜energy-efficiency projects to lower costs, generate new income and strengthen the resilience of operationsโ€™. A total of $1 million went to eight Virginia projects. The money was distributed through loans and grants, one of which went to Regeneration Cycle Farm, LLC, a 94-acre poultry farm in New Market.โ€

โ€œGovernor Glenn Youngkin โ€ฆ announced a landmark land development agreement establishing a public-private framework to transform up to 65,000 acres of previously-mined coal properties in Southwest Virginiaโ€ฆ. Energy DELTA Lab, in coordination with Wise County, VA officials and landowner Energy Transfer, will serve as the primary developer partnering with energy companies and electric utilities to deploy a diverse range of conventional and innovative energy technologies on reclaimed coal mine lands as part of this public-private regional economic development campaign.โ€ The โ€œAbandoned mine reclamation project [is expected] to create โ€˜game-changing opportunitiesโ€™ in Virginia.โ€

Lynchburg is looking to support the nuclear industry and be part of Virginiaโ€™s transition to small nuclear reactors. A โ€œLynchburg company โ€ฆ will supply nuclear fuel for [an] Air Force spacecraft program [and] โ€ฆ will work on a team developing a nuclear fission reactor that would provide electricity to space vehicles.โ€ โ€œA French nuclear power company with its United States headquarters in Lynchburg is ramping up hiring to meet a growing global need for clean, low-carbon energy.โ€

Transportation

โ€œItโ€™s been about a year since Dominion Energy began offering its Virginia customers discounts on installing infrastructure to charge electric vehicles and no one has signed up to take advantage of them, according to a recent bi-annual report filed with electric utility regulators. Despite a lack of participation, Dominion sees the program, known as the Charging Tariffs, as a way to help Virginiaโ€™s transition to electric vehicles (EVs) by making the ability to charge them more accessible to business and low-income communities.โ€ โ€œThe number of folks driving electric vehicles in Virginia has grown by roughly 31,000 since 2021, according to data released by the Department of Motor Vehicles. That number is expected to keep climbing as Virginia works toward a goal of requiring all new cars sold to be electric by 2035โ€ฆ. A spokesperson for Dominion Energy said Virginia will need thousands more charging stations to support electric vehicle adoption over the next decade. Thatโ€™s why the energy company is rolling out programs and offering incentives to encourage businesses and residents to install infrastructure.โ€

โ€œCharlottesville โ€ฆ relaunched an electric vehicle charging grant program to incentivize commercial sites to deploy new charging stations. Preference will be given to charging stations located near retail and commercials sites which would allow EV drivers to patronize local businesses while charging their vehicles.โ€

โ€œAfter criticism over parts of a proposal to overhaul the stateโ€™s transportation funding system, Virginia officials are considering creating a middle-tier application cap for transportation projects in more suburban or smaller urban areas, including several cities in Hampton Roads, Roanoke and Alexandria.โ€ โ€œPlanning officials in the Shenandoah Valley and central Virginia fear proposals to change Virginiaโ€™s transportation funding system could significantly reduce state funding for smaller transportation projects for cyclists and pedestriansโ€ฆ. Some of the proposals being considered by the [Commonwealth transportation] board include favoring larger transportation projects over smaller ones, lowering the number of applications local governments and planning organizations can submit and reducing the weight given to land use in applications. Significantly, many bike and pedestrian projects could go unfunded under the proposed changes.โ€ The Commonwealth Transportation Board will adopt changes in December.

โ€œThe New River Valley Regional Commission recently developed an interactive plan to highlight existing bikeway, walkway, and water trails throughout the region. Community stakeholders, local government, and transportation professionals identified areas where infrastructure could enhance alternative transportation capabilities in the New River Valley. The Bike-Ped-Paddle Plan presents a vision of safe, reliable, healthy, and environmentally-friendly alternatives to motorized transportation.โ€ [See opinion pieces below.]

Fossil Fuels

โ€œA federal appeals court โ€ฆ denied a request from six landowners to stop construction of the Mountain Valley Pipeline on their property while their lawsuit is pending. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia turned down a petition for an emergency injunction โ€ฆ. In what is believed to be the last pending legal action involving pipeline construction in Virginia, the landowners are challenging Mountain Valleyโ€™s use of eminent domain, which it employed in 2018 to take their land for the natural gas pipeline.โ€

โ€œDominionโ€™s Proposed Virginia Power Plant Casts Doubt on Its Commitments to Clean Energy.

The company has proposed building a natural gas facility in Chesterfield, Virginia, despite laws mandating it reach zero-emissions by 2045.โ€

Climate and Environment

Chesapeake Bay, Air, Water, Land and Wildlife

โ€œThe Chesapeake Bay Program recently announced water quality standards attainment measurements for 2009 through 2022. Those measurements indicate that Virginiaโ€™s reported pollution controls achieved 84% of the 2025 reduction goal for nitrogen, 70% of the reduction goal for phosphorus, and 100% of the reduction goal for sedimentโ€ฆ. DEQ staff โ€ฆ [concluded] the modeled pollution load reduction for phosphorus in Virginia could reach 100% of the federal planning targetโ€ฆ.โ€

โ€œAgriculture is the largest source of nutrient pollution to the Chesapeake, and states are relying on farmers to achieve the overwhelming majority of nutrient reductions needed to meet Bay goals. But those largely voluntary actions often cost farmers money, increase their workload and reduce productivity, which in turn hurts future income. Uncertainty over what is expected of farmers and whether their actions are making a difference can make it more difficult to get people to actโ€ฆ. Bay Program records show that state and federal agencies have spent more than $2 billion to help reduce runoff from farms over the last decade. But it remains unclear what has been achieved, at least in computer models used to assess progress.โ€

โ€œThis summer was โ€œfavorableโ€ for species in the Chesapeake Bay, according to a recent report from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. In the report, researchers said the bay experienced a โ€œcooler-than-average summerโ€ from June to August. The report used data from the past 20 years, and in addition to cooler temperatures, healthier oxygen levels were found in the bayโ€™s water.โ€

โ€œThe James Riverโ€™s health has slightly improved but its โ€˜founding fishโ€™ havenโ€™t returnedโ€, according to the โ€œnonprofit James River Association [that] gave the waterway an overall B gradeโ€ฆ in its biennial assessment.โ€

โ€œVirginia is furthering efforts to combat the illegal reptile and amphibian trade in the Commonwealth through a resolution passed โ€ฆ by the Board of Wildlife Resources. The resolution mainly prioritizes the protection of Virginiaโ€™s native turtle species โ€” considered one of the most vulnerable groups of vertebrates worldwide โ€” which face significant threats and population decline due to unsustainable poaching.โ€

โ€œIn the Chesapeake Bay region, states such as Pennsylvania, Maryland and Virginia have added protective laws and funding to keep common species common and save dwindling species. But the species they champion face increasing threats. The agencies cite unrelenting destruction and fragmentation of key habitat, as well as diseases; invasive plants, insects and animals such as wild boar and nutria; impacts of overabundant deer; the poaching and illicit sales of rare specimens; and a changing climateโ€ฆ. No wonder the endangered species list for all three states is at an all-time highโ€ฆ. Altogether, Pennsylvania has 428 living organisms in danger of disappearing from the landscape. Maryland has 346 and Virginia, which uses a โ€œcritically imperiledโ€ category, has 873.โ€

โ€œResidents in Newport Newsโ€™ Southeast Community and Norfolkโ€™s Lamberts Point have complained for decades about coal dust pollution from passing trains, saying it causes sickness and dirties their homesโ€ฆ. Coal mined from Appalachia has been transported through these communities for more than a centuryโ€ฆ. Residents say their homes, yards, and anything left outside is coated in coal dust by the passing open top trainsโ€ฆ. A new state study โ€ฆ [will deploy] monitors to test air quality and assess potential health risks associated with dust from the coal storage and transportation facilities in Newport News and Norfolk. The Department of Environmental Quality [DEQ] study, called the Tidewater Air Monitoring Evaluation project, will measure and analyze toxic metals and particulates in the air in the two communities and use the information to conduct health risk assessments. While residents appreciate the effort to further study the issue, many are skeptical it will result in meaningful changes.โ€

โ€œAs of 2022, data shows that 9.1 million acres of land in the Chesapeake Bay watershed is permanently protected from development. The acreage accounts for approximately 22 percent of the total land in the region. Nearly 1.64 million acres have been added to permanent protection since 2010, achieving 82 percent of the Protected Land Outcome in the Chesapeake Bay Watershed Agreement. The overall Protected Lands Outcome is expected to be achieved by its 2025 deadline. Protected lands are areas throughout the Chesapeake Bay watershed with cultural, historical, ecological and agricultural value that have been permanently protected. Chesapeake Bay Program partners secure land conservation by holding easements, accepting donations and purchasing properties and development rights.โ€

โ€œFrom atop McAfee Knob, hikers can take in a spectacular panoramic view of the Catawba and Roanoke Valleys, North Mountain, and Tinker Cliffs. Now a significant section of that vista โ€ฆ [has] been conserved thanks to a multi-year effort by the Appalachian Trail Conservancy (ATC) and The Conservation Fund.โ€

โ€œGovernor Glenn Youngkin announced $14.7 million in Virginia Land Conservation Foundation funding for 29 new projectsโ€ฆ. Grants were awarded based on farmland preservation, forest preservation, historic preservation, natural area protection, and open spaces and parks. The project includes land acquisitions for new public outdoor recreational areas and conservation easements to protect active forests and farmland.โ€ In the Central Valley, only Shenandoah County received funding through the grants for two projects.

โ€œAn effort to preserve dark skies in Great Falls recently got a vote of support from the Fairfax County Planning Commission amidst contention within the communityโ€ฆ. Proponents called the proposal a necessary step to preserve dark skies, reduce light pollution, and ensure astronomers can continue to get clear views. Opponents said the changes would decrease safety, were being considered without direct community engagement, and did little to result in a meaningful impact on light pollution. The regulations, which limit outdoor lighting with a half-mile of the observatory, have been in the works for years.โ€

โ€œCounties and towns across the Northern Shenandoah Valley will make significant upgrades to recycling infrastructure after receiving a nearly $4 million grant from the Environmental Protection Agency. The EPA selected the Northern Shenandoah Valley Regional Commission for its Solid Waste Infrastructure for Recycling (SWIFR) grant program โ€ฆ, with the aim of upgrading tire-grinding operations and expanding curbside recycling pickup throughout the region. The commission, which covers five counties and the city of Winchester, was one of only 24 recipients of the grant nationwide.โ€

โ€œAt the edge of Shenandoah National Park โ€ฆ Virginia Department of Forestry [staff] are getting acorns and chestnuts into the groundโ€ฆ. In about 18 months [their efforts] would result in a crop of seedlings that could be sold to landowners and the timber industry. In this way, Virginiaโ€™s arboreal future would be secure โ€” thanks in part to acorn enthusiasts who donated more than a million specimens this year as part of a state programโ€ฆ. The operations at the Crimora nursery use contributions from an acorn donation program that Virginiaโ€™s forestry department has run for about a decade. Last year, the harvest was a formidable eight tons of acorns and nuts โ€” enough to produce 1.5 million seedlings. This year, donors sent 12 tons.โ€

Climate Change and Climate Action Planning

โ€œThe National Climate Assessment is the governmentโ€™s most comprehensive report on how climate change is affecting the U.S., and offers people across the country a window into what we can expect in the years to comeโ€ฆ. The report looks at how the climate impacts everything from health and housing to agriculture, transportation, air quality and local ecosystems. The U.S. Global Change Research Program released the first such assessment in 2000โ€ฆ. [The latest] report is the fifth โ€“ and most dire. It confirms that climate change, driven primarily by the burning of fossil fuels, is already impacting the lives of Americans, and that the country needs to adapt to those impacts even while acting to slash greenhouse gas emissions to prevent the worst-case scenarios. The report finds especially strong impacts in the Southeast region, which includes Virginia and North Carolina.โ€

โ€œIn a partisan vote โ€ฆ, the Prince William Board of County Supervisors approved a plan created by sustainability officials to help the county meet its climate mitigation goals. The Community Energy and Sustainability Master Plan, backed by the boardโ€™s Democratic majority, outlines a vision for how the county can take steps toward being a regional leader in environmentally friendly practices and policies. Republicans in the minority who opposed the plan said it was half-baked and worried about the fiscal implications of eventually implementing policies that address the recommendations. The board in 2020 adopted its climate goals and authorized the Office of Sustainability to develop the master plan to meet those goals. The goals include: Cutting greenhouse gas emission to 50% below 2005 levels by 2030; sourcing all countywide electricity from renewable sources by 2035; achieving 100% renewable electricity in the county government operations by 2030; reaching full carbon neutrality in the county government operations by 2050; becoming a โ€˜climate ready region;โ€™ and making significant progress to toward the goals by 2030.โ€

Drought, Fires, Flooding, Winter Weather Forecast, andโ€ฆ Earthquakes?

We previously provided details about the replenishment of aquifers in Tidewater VA that some jurisdictions are undertaking. Some additional details were recently reported: โ€œSoutheast Virginiaโ€™s massive aquifer is being replenished. Hereโ€™s why that mattersโ€ฆ. Hampton Roads Sanitation District [is drilling and constructing] 10 wells โ€ฆ in the park near the James River Wastewater Treatment Plantโ€ฆ. [The] wells are designed to inject water back into the aquifer, which is an essential source of freshwater in the region, and, like many aquifers across the nation, is in danger of being overdrawnโ€ฆ. The goal of the sanitation districtโ€™s SWIFT Project, or Sustainable Water Initiatives for Tomorrow, is recharging the aquifer by bringing wastewater to drinking water standards, treating it to match existing groundwater chemistry, and injecting it back into the earth. Doing so addresses several environmental concerns, including conservation, saltwater intrusion and land compaction. Water exits the aquifer faster than it can recharge.โ€

โ€œNorfolkโ€™s draft priorities in the state house this year include asks on โ€ฆ funding for one of the cityโ€™s largest projects in a generation. The $2.6 billion Coastal Storm Resiliency Management project is slated to encompass almost 8 miles of floodwalls with various other storm management infrastructure when totally completed over the next decade.โ€ โ€œThirty-eight years after the Flood of โ€™85, Roanoke is still preparing for the next one. Thanks to the cityโ€™s flood reduction project, 44% of the parcels in the cityโ€™s flood control map are now in a lower risk category.โ€

โ€œDrought is getting to be a big problem over a wide part of Virginia. Wildfires are breaking out as there is yet to be any sign of an El Niรฑo-charged wet pattern.โ€ The drought is expanding in the DC, Maryland, and Virginia region. โ€œ

In early November, the Governor declared a state of emergency because of wildfires. โ€œVirginia currently has five active wildfires that have each consumed more than 1,000 acres and are only partly containedโ€ฆ. The U.S. Forest Service โ€ฆ announced restrictions on fires in the George Washington & Jefferson National Forest.โ€ โ€œFour of the five biggest wildfires burning across the western part of Virginia grew] โ€ฆ over the [Nov 11-12] weekend, but four of them are also more containedโ€ฆ.โ€ [The light rain on that weekend] did little to quell the widespread and intensifying drought, [and] cooler temperatures and higher humidity helped slow fire spread and allowed crews better opportunity to contain existing fires.โ€ โ€œUpdated figures from the scene of the Quaker Run Fire [in Madison County] suggest the blaze has consumed more than previously reported.โ€ The Blue Ridge Parkway and Shenandoah National Park announced restrictions. Counties doing so included AlbemarleAugustaRockbridge, and Rockingham counties and the cities of Harrisonburg, Waynesboro, and Staunton. The Virginia Forestry Department recommends all outside burning be delayed.

NOAA, โ€œthe National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration โ€ฆ released its winter outlook, and for many it is good news โ€“ predicting both a warmer winter and a snowier winter than [Virginia saw] last year. The winter weather patterns will be affected by the Pacific Ocean climate pattern known as El Nino.โ€

โ€œA โ€œmuch larger earthquakeโ€ is possible in Stuarts Draft after a series of three small earthquakes over eight days, according to a Virginia Tech professor. All three earthquakes in Augusta County measured between 2.2 and 2.4 magnitude with a depth starting on Oct. 15 at 2.4 km; progressing on Oct. 22 at 3.5 km; and 8.5 km on Oct. 23.โ€

Opinions, Letters to the Editor (LTEs), and Blogs

โ€œA conservative endorsement of solar energy in Orange Countyโ€ by the Director of Conservatives for Clean Energy Virginia โ€“ Daily Progress

โ€œWhy itโ€™s better to let counties review solar projects case-by-caseโ€ by the Virginia Policy Advisor for The Center for Infrastructure and Economic Development โ€“ Virginia Mercury

โ€œOn solar, as with all else: Follow the moneyโ€, LTE by a senior writer at the Union of Concerned Scientists โ€“ Washington Post

Fauquier Webert PJM Routing Concerns Letter 101823 โ€“ by a Virginia Delegate representing Fauquier County to the Chairman, Transmission Expansion Advisory Committee, of PJM (grid manager for Virginia and other nearby states).

โ€œWind turbines looming on our horizonโ€ LTE by a Stephens City resident โ€“ The Winchester Star

โ€œDeveloping offshore wind in Virginia takes time. Thatโ€™s a good thing.โ€ By the clean energy and climate justice policy manager at Virginia Conservation Network and the offshore energy program director at Sierra Club Virginia Chapter โ€“ The Virginian-Pilot 

โ€œSCC Approves Paying Extra for Fuel As โ€˜Reliefโ€™โ€ in a Baconโ€™s Rebellion blog post

โ€œDriving to the Future in the South,โ€ aNational Resources Defense Council blog post.

Check out โ€ฆ

  • The Virginia Native Plant Finder tool if youโ€™re seeking native plants.
  • The Virginia Sierra Club Potomac Groupโ€™s Webinar: โ€œThe Good, the Bad, the Breezy: Offshore Wind in Virginia and Nationwideโ€ฆ. [T]he picture is currently not so clear for other East Coast offshore wind projects [though Virginiaโ€™s project is looking good]. Learn about the challenges overcome and still facing offshore wind, the implications of those challenges have on our one current Virginia project AND future offshore wind projects in the works off Virginiaโ€™s coast.โ€ The event will happen December 4 at 7 pm. Register here.
  • This Blue Ridge Country editorโ€™s piece on โ€œThe Beauty of Rail Trails โ€“ Riding (Farther) to Lunch.โ€

Why not โ€ฆ

The Climate Action Alliance of the Valley (CAAV) is a non-profit, grassroots group in the Central Shenandoah Valley that educates legislators and the public about the implications of the Earthโ€™s worsening climate crisis.

Climate and Energy News Roundup โ€“ November 2023

Women are at the forefront of collaborative efforts to support each other in the face of our changing climate. In many countries, womenโ€™s intimate knowledge of the land means they are quicker to spot environmental changes, to learn from them, and out of necessity, find ways to adapt. โ€”Christiana Figueres

Our Climate Crisis

Recent research indicates that accelerated ice melt in west Antarctica is inevitable for the rest of the century. Even drastic emissions cuts in the coming decades will not slow the melting. If completely lost, the ice sheet would push up ocean levels by about 16 feet. The implications are โ€œdireโ€ and some coastal cities may have to be abandoned.

The world has sweltered through the hottest spell in human history this summer. A conservative tally estimates that extreme weather disasters took more than 18,000 lives, drove at least 150,000 people from their homes, affected hundreds of millions of others and caused billions of dollars of damage.

After our summer of record-breaking heat, things got even worse in September as global temperatures rose far above normal. The average temperature was 1.7 degrees Fahrenheit above the 1991-2020 average for September. Thatโ€™s the warmest margin above average for a month in 83 years of record keeping.

The unexpected heavy rainfall and flash flooding in New York City at the end of September is an example of how small storm systems can become severe because of global warming. This followed similar downpours in July that created catastrophic flooding that struck parts of Vermont and the Hudson Valley.

Politics and Policy

Clean energy, data centers, and utility influence in Virginia is up for a vote in the off-year election this fall. If he can achieve a Republican majority in both houses of the General Assembly, Governor Youngkin aims to repeal previous clean energy legislation. Particularly in his crosshairs are the Virginia Clean Energy Act, participation in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, and the Clean Cars law.

At their first Climate Action Conference on Sept. 30, Fairfax County officials said that residents are underutilizing publicly-funded incentives to make their homes more green. Greeting a crowd of community members County Supervisor James Walkinshaw said the focus of the conference was to give residents โ€œall the actionable information and the tools you need to reduce your emissions and save money.โ€

The European Union has launched a huge climate experiment by imposing a Europe-wide tax on carbon in imported goods. It could have global ripple effects across the entire globe by pushing high-emitting industries to clean up their production. It could also incentivize other countries to launch their own carbon taxes on imported goods. In these respects it could end up being one of the most important climate policies.

As big businesses like Amazon, Microsoft, Walmart, and Apple ramp up efforts to reduce their carbon footprint, theyโ€™re putting pressure on their suppliers to do the same. Consumers, investors, regulators, and governments are pushing firms for more progress and transparency.

The US Department of Energy announced the largest-ever investment in Americaโ€™s electrical grid. The $3.5 billion in grants will expand capacity for wind and solar power, harden power lines against extreme weather, integrate batteries and electric vehicles, and build out microgrids. This will represent more than $8 billion in investment when matched by funds from state and local governments and utility and industry partners.

The Biden administration has green-lighted a record low number of new offshore oil wells. Experts say this decline reflects economics and production strategy as much as shifts in federal oil policy. Many climate activists fault the White House for holding any oil sales, while drillers and GOP allies of the industry say that so few opportunities to buy new drilling rights is undermining national production.

Beliefs on the severity of climate change have not shifted significantly among religious groups in the United States. In fact, among white evangelicals the view that the Earth is in a climate crisis actually dropped from 13% in 2014 to 8% today.

Energy

The International Energy Agency predicts that global demand for oil, natural gas and coal will peak by 2030. Their executive director Fatih Birol says, โ€œThe transition to clean energy is happening worldwide and itโ€™s unstoppable.โ€ Even so, a peak in fossil fuel use wonโ€™t be enough to stop global warming.

New clean energy grid battery installations are growing exponentially in the U.S., especially in Texas and California. The energy they supply is still just a drop in the bucket of overall consumption but they can deliver quick bursts of power at key moments during times of high demand. Battles with grid electric supply are won or lost on the margins and the megawatts that batteries instantly contribute during moments of crisis can avert power outages.

Electricity production is the biggest source of carbon emissions in the world. Data from a clean-energy think-tank report shows that in the first half of this year, global power-sector emissions rose by just 0.2%, thanks largely to the embrace of wind and solar power. This indicates that the world is approaching a peak in electricity carbon emissions.

The Interior Department approved a plan to install up to 176 giant wind turbines off the coast of Virginia. This clears the way for what will be the nationโ€™s largest offshore wind farm yet. The project to be built by Dominion Energy will produce enough clean electricity to power more than 900,000 homes.

After more than a year of evaluating competing proposals, the US Department of Energy has picked seven โ€œclean hydrogen hubsโ€ where it hopes to turn $7 billion dollars of federal investment into the seeds of a clean hydrogen economy. The industries expected to use the clean hydrogen range from chemicals, steel and fertilizer production to shipping, trucking and power generation.

Through its Rural Energy for America Program, the  U.S. Department of Agriculture awarded $266 million in funding to eight renewable energy and energy-efficiency projects in Virginia. Included was $115,880 awarded to Regeneration Cycle, LLC in Rockingham County for two solar systems for four organic poultry houses. The owner, Corwin Heatwole, said he always wanted to go solar and this project made it possible.

Climate Justice

In a new climate letter, Pope Francis takes direct aim at climate change deniers and castigates Western nations, particularly the United States, for irresponsible lifestyles causing irreparable harm to the planet. He criticizes oil and gas companies for greenwashing new fossil fuel projects and calls for more ambitious efforts in the West to tackle the climate crisis. He says that โ€œavoiding an increase of a tenth of a degree in the global temperature would already suffice to alleviate some suffering for many people.โ€

The Mountain Valley Pipeline is now on a mad dash to the finish because of West Virginia Senator Joe Manchinโ€™s insistence that Congress approve it to get his vote to raise the national debt ceiling. It stretches just over 300 miles from the northern border of West Virginia to southern Virginia. It traverses ecologically fragile terrain including hundreds of bodies of water and steep mountain slopes and has upended the lives of people who live in its path.

Electric bikes promise to make a significant contribution to driving down greenhouse gas emissions in transportation. The upfront cost, however, puts them out of reach for many people. Thatโ€™s why cities and states across the United States are rolling out programs to make e-bikes more accessible to lower-income residents. E-bikes also offer other benefits including more mobility than public transit and at a much lower cost than a car.

Climate Action

The Harrisonburg City Council voted to add a set of community engagement goals to the cityโ€™s Environmental Action Plan. People who live and work in Harrisonburg will be enlisted to help reduce carbon emissions through efforts like reducing car travel and planting trees. Keith Thomas, the sustainability and environmental manager for the cityโ€™s Public Works Department, said, โ€œTotal emissions are what matter at the end of the day, so thatโ€™s what weโ€™re focusing on.โ€

Agrivoltaicsโ€”on-farm solar arrays combined with grazing or other forms of agricultureโ€”is still rare in California. They could, however, be a game-changer in a state with lots of sunshine where many farmers are struggling to plan for a future with limited groundwater. It could be vital to preserving food production as many farmers face pressure to retire parts of their land to comply with water conservation regulations.

Virginia Tech has been awarded an $80 million grant from the US Department of Agriculture to participate in a climate-smart farming program. The pilot program will pay farmers to voluntarily implement climate-smart practices that help reduce greenhouse gases. The university says that if the program can be scaled up nationally, it could help reduce agricultural emissions by 55% โ€” and reduce total emissions in the U.S. by 8%, after 10 years.

A startup business in Northern Virgina called โ€œLambMowersโ€ is a fun and ecologically innovative approach to how we care for our lawns. The owner, Cory Suter, who grew up here in the Valley, began his flock of sheep as part of his 5 acre permaculture farm in Fairfax. He then came up with the idea of making his sheep available to mow his neighborsโ€™ lawns. Turf grass, including residential and commercial lawns, golf courses and similar landscapes, is by far the largest cultivated crop in the United States, three times bigger than corn.

An often overlooked climate solution is a compact 15 minute city where we can access key things in our livesโ€”work, food, schools and recreationโ€”within a short walk, bike, or transit ride of our home. This concept is catching on in urban planning even though it is running up against existing zoning restrictions and even recently hatched conspiracy theories.

Scientists from the University of Virginia, doing research on the Eastern Shore, have discovered that seagrass beds can permanently lock in carbon. They capture and retain carbon for centuries even in situations where the seagrass dies off. This means that seagrass conservation and restoration can be a significant climate change solution.

Rachel Brown, a retired quilt store owner, recently had a solar array installed on her Augusta County home free of charge through the Income and Age Qualifying Solar program of Dominion Energy. When she first heard about the program, she thought it was too good to be true but her trusted nephew Everett Brubaker, who works for Community Housing Partners, convinced her it was legitimate. Her house was first given a free energy efficiency makeoverโ€”as her nephew explainedโ€”solar โ€œdessertโ€ follows weatherization โ€œvegetables.โ€

Fallen leaves are a really important wildlife habitat. So why not be lazy this fall. You will want to remove most of the leaves from your grass but you can place some of them in certain places and put others in your compost bin. Allow a little chaos in parts of your garden. Thatโ€™s really beneficial for the soil, the animals, and the insects that need to share these landscapes with us.

Action Alert

You are invited to participate in a tree planting event at Harrisonburg Mennonite Church on November 11. We will start with coffee and pastries at 8:00 a.m. in the church fellowship hall. We need to have a count of those who plan to attend beforehand so we can estimate the amount of food and coffee required. If you are interested, please email Steve Pardini: pardini.steve [at] hotmail.com

This is the second phase of a four-phase project to plant 250 trees. The goals of this project are: 1.) To beautify the HMC campus, 2.) Create a spiritual and natural place for meditation, fellowship, and recreation, 3.) Steward the land, sequester carbon, mitigate water runoff, and reduce summer heat.

Earl Zimmerman
CAAV Steering Committee

Virginia Environmental News Roundup for October 2023

The Climate Action Alliance of the Valley is pleased to provide Harrisonburgโ€™s The Citizen with a monthly survey of energy and environmental news stories about Virginia.

With their permission, we are re-posting these pieces here after they appear in the Citizen.


The link to this piece as first published byย theย Citizenย isย HERE.

Statewide Environmental News Roundup for October 2023

Energy

Regulations and Utilities

Last month, we included articles about the General Assemblyโ€™s failure to fill two of the three vacancies on the State Corporation Commission (SCC). A former judge, who served temporarily, left for another position leaving only one. Another former judge will step in temporarily. The SCC needs at least two judges to carry out its work.

We previously shared articles about Virginia Beach residentsโ€™ opposition to power lines coming ashore from wind farms through their neighborhoods. This concern will affect many coastal and inland communities. โ€œAs Chesapeake Bay drainage states and the nation move to fulfill bold commitments to convert to renewable energy in the next few decades, an inconvenient truth has become apparent: It canโ€™t be done without many more transmission lines. Through neighborhoods, along roads and across mountains, the nationโ€™s network of power lines needs to double or triple in the next decade if the clean energy revolution is to succeed, warn the U.S. Department of Energy, scientists, environmental groups and many policymakers.โ€

There is growing concern about the lack of regulatory oversight of ratepayer costs from utilitiesโ€™ transmission line growth. An Ohio consumer group has filed a complaint with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) that โ€œelectric customers have fallen into a โ€˜regulatory gapโ€™ thatโ€™s allowed billions of dollars of transmission construction to happen without oversight of need, prudence or cost effectivenessโ€ฆ. [T]he same concern exists across much of the nation, so much so that the commission itself has weighed whether more monitoring of transmission spending is necessary.โ€

โ€œ[T]he Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (โ€œDEQโ€) published a Notice of Intended Regulatory Action (โ€œNOIRAโ€) concerning amendments to the Small Solar Renewable Energy Projects Permit Regulation (the Solar PBR), 9VAC15-60. The Solar PBR regulation allows solar developers to obtain a state permit to construct and operate solar facilities without obtaining a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity from the โ€ฆ [SCC]. DEQ intends to conform the Solar PBR regulation to Chapter 688 of the 2022 Acts of Assembly to require a mitigation plan detailing reasonable actions to avoid, minimize, or otherwise mitigate impacts to prime agricultural soils and forest lands. This regulatory action would apply to solar projects that disturb more than 10 acres of prime agricultural soils, or 50 acres of contiguous forest lands, and to projects that would disturb forest lands enrolled in a forestry preservation program. However, projects would be grandfathered if the interconnection request is applied for and received by December 31, 2024.โ€

Wason Center for Civic Leadership survey โ€œof 800 interviews of Virginia likely votersโ€ found that โ€œa majority (65% to 26%) of Virginia voters also support staying in โ€ฆ [RGGI], a program that enters the Commonwealth into a carbon cap and trade program with other states in the region to reduce carbon pollution. Younger voters also show higher support for remaining in RGGI than voters age 45+ (71% to 62%), while more women prefer to stay in the program than men (70% to 59%).โ€ See opinion pieces below. **

Data Centers, Energy Storage

โ€œData centers should be further away from homes, schools and national parks. They shouldnโ€™t be allowed to tower over their neighbors and they should be required to be less noisy. Those are among the recommendations three organizations of residents from Fauquier, Loudoun and Prince William counties proposed in an effort to guide local government officials on siting data centers and to avoid negative impact on local residents. Leaders of the groups said they planned to deliver their packet of proposals to their respective county boards immediately.โ€

โ€œHow [a Haymarket-area] project was approvedโ€”with little public opposition, little skepticism from county officials, and the acquiescence of the homeownersโ€™ associationโ€”is a rich tale. The stew includes apparent misrepresentations or misunderstandings, an agreeable county planning office and resident apathy amid the COVID epidemic. Pointedly, the record shows that key decision-makers mainly fretted about the routing of power lines to the project and missed the elephant in the roomโ€”the sheer size of the buildings.โ€ Neighbors to another Prince William data center found its noise levels intolerable and worked with Amazonโ€™s engineers to alleviate the problem. So far, the decibel levels have been halved. โ€œThe work is not done. Residents say the screechy part of the noise remains, and Amazon is working on that too.โ€

โ€œTwo families who agreed to sell their properties to a data center developer involved in the controversial Prince William Digital Gateway want out of the deal. Lawyers for both families say their contracts are no longer valid because they include a rezoning date that wasnโ€™t met. The matter is now playing out in federal courtโ€ฆ. The court documents also shed new light on the deadlines set in the landownersโ€™ sale contracts and the rush to set public hearings on the rezonings before the end of the year.โ€ โ€œA U.S. district court judge โ€ฆ ruled against [the] two families who wanted out of the deal they madeโ€ฆ. The ruling, which says the land sale agreements are valid and landowners have no basis to terminate their contracts, removes a legal hurdle for developers involved in the massive new data center corridor proposed near the Manassas National Battlefield Park.โ€

โ€œFollowing four public hearings โ€ฆ, the Spotsylvania County Board of Supervisors approved rezoning requests for four projects related to data center development. With the rezoning approvals, the county moved closer to joining the data center boom in Virginia as developers move from Northern Virginia to less populated areas in Spotsylvania, Stafford and King George counties.โ€

The Fairfax County Planning Commission approved a new data center in Chantilly โ€œover vocal protests from members of the publicโ€ฆ. This recommendation comes after months of discord over the project and amidst a broader debate over data centers in the county. Ultimately, county staff concluded that a data center or warehouse was an acceptable use for the land in question.โ€

Renewable Energy, Energy Efficiency, and Nuclear

โ€œEnergy Firms, Green Groups and Others Reach[ed a] Deal on Solar Farms. The agreement could help speed up the development of large solar projects that are often bogged down by fights over land use and environmental concerns.โ€ It remains to be seen what effects the deal will have in Virginia.

โ€œ[Bristol Virginia] City leaders are considering a new use for the cityโ€™s vexing landfill once all of its issues are eventually resolved: as a possible solar energy siteโ€ฆ. [Its] City Council unanimously approved seeking a state brownfields grant that could be the first step toward locating solar panels there to generate electricity.โ€ Augusta County residents are speaking up about a proposed large-scale solar facility near New Hope. โ€œThe Stop Big Solar in Staunton group has filed a legal challenge against the project.โ€ Botetourt County supervisors approved a small-scale solar project that is part of โ€œDominion Energyโ€™s Virginia Community Solar Pilot Program.โ€ โ€œThe South Central Virginia Business Alliance held a membership and networking meeting โ€ฆ to attract new local businesses looking to tap into the burgeoning solar sector and get their piece of the pie from projects being developed across Southside Virginia.โ€ See opinion pieces below. ***

โ€œScheduled to begin offshore construction in 2024, [Dominionโ€™s] Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind [OSW] is a 2.6โ€‘gigawatt offshore wind energy project that will consist of 176 wind turbines located 27 miles off the coast of Virginia Beach, three offshore substations, undersea cables and new onshore transmission infrastructure to deliver emissions-free wind power to homes and businesses.โ€ โ€œThe first monopiles for the โ€ฆ Wind project โ€ฆ arrived at the Port of Virginiaโ€ฆ. In total, โ€ฆ [there will be] 176 monopile foundations that are up to 83 meters long, weigh 1,538 tons and have a diameter of up to 9.5 meters.โ€ Despite anticipated pullback from OSW investors and developers following a New York regulatorโ€™s decision about passing costs along to ratepayers, Dominion Energy is apparently planning for its 2nd โ€œMassive Offshore Wind Farm Off Virginia.โ€

Fairfax County โ€œhosted the countyโ€™s first Climate Action Conference last monthโ€ฆ. [Its purpose] โ€œwas to give residents โ€˜all the actionable information and the tools you need to reduce your emissions and save money.โ€™โ€ฆ Low-income households can apply for the Weatherization Assistance Program, which offers home energy audits and makes necessary improvements and repairs to heating and cooling systems. The improvements are free of charge and may include work on windows and doors, roof repairs and HVAC sealing, thereby improving efficiency and lowering lower energy bills.โ€ Other programs were also highlighted. We previously provided information about this program happening now in the Valley. For Dominion customers there is a โ€œVirginia solar program [that] delivers clean energy to elderly, low-income households. A three-year pilot spurred by 2019 legislation, the Dominion Energy program offers weatherization services and solar panels to qualified customers free of charge.โ€ This story highlights the experience of a Dominion customer in Augusta County who benefited from the program.

โ€œA year ago, the governor said he wants the region [SWVA} to host an SMR [Small Nuclear Reactor]. A study identified [seven] sites across four counties; many are on former coal mine lands, and several are close to population centersโ€ฆ. SMRs are smaller, simpler versions of traditional nuclear reactors that produce about a third of the power produced by the big reactors. They can be โ€ฆ cheaper than constructing a large reactorโ€ฆ. No SMRs have yet been built in the United States โ€ฆ. [S]everal environmental groups have raised concerns about some of the sites, particularly those that are in or near towns and so are closer to homes and businesses. But the biggest complaint has been that so far, the public is being left out of the process.โ€ See opinion piece below. ****

Transportation

The Governor has made known his opposition to a federal regulation, and a Virginia law, that would accelerate the use of EVs. His energy plan objected to the Virginia Clean Economy Act and challenged legislation passed by Virginia in the 2021 session to adopt vehicle emissions regulations set forth by California โ€ฆ.โ€ โ€œWest Virginia and neighboring Virginia have joined a 26 state coalition that is challenging a Biden administration rule that seeks to expedite the nationโ€™s transition to electric vehicles. The states are challenging a proposed National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) rule โ€ฆ [to] effectively mandate automakers to shift to electric vehicles.โ€ See opinion pieces below.*

โ€œVirginiaโ€™s Community Climate Collaborative (C3) released a new report [โ€œAlternative Fuels for Transit Buses: Whatโ€™s the Best Option for Your Transit Agency? (Vol.1)] to inform localities on the best alternative fuel options aligned with climate objectives, public health, environmental justice, fiscal responsibility, and service qualityโ€ฆ. The report โ€ฆ focuses on three alternative fuel choices โ€” battery-electric buses (BEBs), compressed natural gas (CNGs) buses, and fuel-cell electric buses (FCEBs) โ€” and their ability to meet ridership needs as a sustainable solution for public transit.โ€

โ€œA new report finds Virginia has โ€œpoorโ€ transportation infrastructure in multiple areas .โ€ฆ The report, โ€œKeeping Virginia Mobile: Providing a Modern, Sustainable Transportation System in the Old Dominion State,โ€ was released by TRIP, a transportation non-profit in Washington DC. The report first highlighted how Virginia transportation has improved thanks to past state and federal funding.โ€

Fossil Fuels

The Mountain Valley Pipeline (MVP) construction continues and so does the opposition and concerns about safety and further destruction. โ€œAfter years of protests and lawsuits, the natural gas pipeline is almost finished.โ€ This story describes how the lives of those who live near the path are being affected by what it calls โ€œJoe Manchinโ€™s โ€ฆ Pipeline.โ€ Proximity to construction is bringing โ€œfear and angerโ€ following the negative effects of construction and its accompanying destruction of property. โ€œIn the past, the joint venture of five energy companies building the pipeline has paused construction during the winter months, in the years when it was not already stalled by litigation that has long delayed the $6.6 billion project.โ€

โ€œA Montgomery County judge declined to issue an injunction โ€ฆ against a woman described by Mountain Valley Pipeline lawyers as a leading opponent of the highly divisive project.โ€ โ€œThree protestors were arrested after attaching themselves to โ€ฆ MVPโ€ฆ equipment.โ€ โ€œA group of landowners is seeking an emergency injunction from a federal appeals court that would pause construction of the โ€ฆ Pipeline on their property while their lawsuit is pending. Three couples who own three tracts of land along the pipelineโ€™s route are challenging the companyโ€™s use of eminent domain, which it invoked in 2018 to take their land for the natural gas pipeline.โ€

This fall and winter, work will continue when it is safe to do so [according to the developer] .โ€ฆ State environmental regulators have cited Mountain Valley more than 300 times with violating erosion and sediment control regulations since 2018, allowing harmful sediment to be washed from the pipelineโ€™s 125-foot wide right of way.โ€ โ€œAfter repeatedly telling investors and the public that it planned have the natural gas pipeline in service by the end of this year,โ€ the developer announced a delay in the anticipated completion date to 1st quarter 2024Costs will be greater than previously stated.

โ€œA federal safety agency is ordering โ€ฆ [MVP] to take additional steps to inspect and repair any sections of pipe that may have been damaged by exposure to the elements during long delays in construction. The action, which [followed] an informal consultation with [the] lead pipeline partner โ€ฆ, was taken to address concerns that prolonged exposure to sunlight may have worn thin a protective coating on the pipe meant to curb corrosion once itโ€™s buried.โ€ โ€œFollowing a federal government agencyโ€™s proposed safety order, the pipelineโ€™s operator says an independent third-party engineering firm will evaluate the integrity of the pipeline for the remainder of the projectโ€™s construction.โ€

North Carolinaโ€™s legislature overrode the Governorโ€™s veto of a bill that โ€œloosens water quality requirements for a controversial pipeline project called MVP Southgate. The N.C. Department of Environmental Quality has denied water quality certifications for the project in the past, but the bill would make it easier for MVP Southgate to get certified.โ€

The Sierra Club explained its opposition to โ€œDominion Energy [โ€˜s proposed] โ€ฆ Gas-Burning Chesterfield Plant Near Disadvantaged Communities [noting that the] โ€ฆ peaker plant, if built, would be the largest in Virginiaโ€ฆ. Peaker plants like the one Dominion is proposing are also known for emitting pollutants harmful to human health such as small particulate matter, nitrous oxides, and ozone. These can form particulate matter (PM2.5), which can enter the bloodstream and intensify health conditions and lead to premature death. The company wants to site the plant near the James Riverโ€”a waterway that is already rife with pollution from heavy industrializationโ€”near neighborhoods that are historically disadvantaged and primarily composed of communities of color.โ€

Climate and Environment

Chesapeake Bay, Air, Water, and Wildlife

โ€œMore than a dozen environmental groups have petitioned that the EPA be more strict on regulations regarding coal pollution from open-top trains, and the group cites communities in Hampton Roads as evidence of a need for changeโ€ฆ. The petition โ€” signed by the Sierra Club, New Virginia Majority and 14 other groups โ€” calls for the agency to require coal train operators to obtain a permit for their water pollution. In the petition, the groups argue that coal pollution is damaging local aquatic life and human health with heavy metals and toxic chemicals including arsenic, cadmium, chromium and mercury.โ€

โ€œThe commercial harvest of blue crabs has been extended in Virginia as the crab population trends upwardโ€ฆ. The blue crab is an iconic part of the Chesapeake Bay, commercially and culturally. Their harvest brings in tens of millions of pounds of crab annually. The Chesapeake Bay is home to hundreds of millions of blue crabs, according to a yearly survey by the Virginia Institute of Marine Science and the Fisheries Service of the Maryland Department of Natural Resourcesโ€ฆ. The Bayโ€™s blue crab population had been on a four-year decline before this year. The crabs were at their lowest population in 33 years in 2022, according to the survey. The recent 42% increase prompted state agencies to expand commercial fishing timelines.โ€

โ€œThe U.S. Environmental Protection Agency will invest $9.6 million into restoring the Chesapeake Bay with projects funded by the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. More than $1.9 million in Watershed Restoration Grants will go toward two organizations in Virginia to help protect and restore Virginiaโ€™s portion of the Chesapeake Bay watershed.โ€

Drought, Flooding, andโ€ฆ Earthquakes?

โ€œThe city of Norfolk โ€ฆ secured its first federal grant to help offset the cost of building a 20-plus acre park in the St. Paulโ€™s neighborhood that will double as a flooding mitigation tool. [The $4 million grant] isโ€ฆ from the U.S. Department of Agriculture Forest Serviceโ€ฆ. โ€

โ€œMore than a year after a devastating flash flood hit Buchanan and Tazewell counties, residents whose property was damaged or destroyed can finally start the process of applying for state flood relief money. โ€ฆ [The delegate] instrumental in securing the $18 million, said โ€ฆ he hopes those who qualify will receive the money before the end of the year.โ€

Augusta County experienced a trifecta of earthquakes over eight days this month according to โ€œthe U.S. Geological Survey websiteโ€ฆ. Small earthquakes are uncommon in Virginia as a whole. However, there have been roughly 100 earthquakes in the last 23 years throughout the state, according to the USGS. Most register under 3.0 magnitude. Mineral, Va., has been the site of higher magnitude quakes with one registering 4.5 and one registering 5.8 in 2011. In the last 10 years, smaller earthquakes have also been registered in Louisa, Deerfield, Forest and Verona.โ€

Opinions

* โ€œTransition to electric vehicles faces a bumpy roadโ€ by the โ€œpresident of Skyline Policy Risk Group and a former deputy assistant secretary for policy at the U.S. Department of Transportationโ€ โ€“ The Virginianโ€‘Pilot

* โ€œVirginia should make its own decisions about EVs [by] a distinguished fellow at The Heritage Foundationโ€ โ€” The Virginian-Pilot

* โ€œWant to help Virginia consumers? Reverse course on electric vehicle mandateโ€ by a former Virginia governor โ€“ Richmond Times-Dispatch

** โ€œYoungkinโ€™s RGGI repeal is a bad deal for Virginiansโ€ by the Executive Director of Virginia League of Conservation Voters โ€“ The Virginian Pilot

** โ€Whatโ€™s at stake if RGGI disappears in Virginia?โ€ โ€“ Bay Journal article

** Letter to the Editor (LTE) by a Virginian Pilot reader in response to preceding opinion. โ€œWe canโ€™t afford to wait on Davisโ€™ vague claim that the marketplace will eventually do its magic. This is not a โ€œtomorrowโ€ problem; it is a โ€œtwo weeks ago yesterdayโ€ problem.โ€

** A Loudoun Times-Mirror reader voiced similar support of RGGI.

*** โ€œUnfounded concerns about photovoltaic module toxicity and waste are slowing decarbonizationโ€ by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory โ€“ published in Nature magazine and reported in Inside Climate News

*** โ€œSolar farms and agriculture can coexistโ€ by a Frederick County resident โ€“ Winchester Star

*** โ€œUtility Scale Solar is Coming to a Farm Near Youโ€ by an Augusta County farmer โ€“ Getting More on the Ground

**** โ€œSmall modular nuclear reactors: Unlikely, unaffordable, dirty and dangerousโ€ by The Appalachia Peace Education Center in Abingdon โ€“ News

**** LTE by a Bedford County resident. โ€œNuclear power is harmfulโ€ โ€“ Roanoke Times

โ€œUp for a vote in this election: clean energy, data centers and utility influenceโ€ by a Virginia Energy expert โ€“ Virginia Mercury

โ€œLeaky pipes, unpaid bills: Richmond really needs a public utilities commissionโ€ by โ€œan active volunteer with Electrify RVA and a renewable energy software engineerโ€ โ€“ The Richmond Times-Dispatch

โ€œVirginia General Assembly must build on the cost savings of the IRAโ€ by โ€œthe executive director of Freedom Virginia [and] โ€ฆ the policy director for the Virginia League of Conservation Votersโ€ โ€” Dogwood

Check out โ€ฆ

  • The Garden Club of Virginiaโ€™s 65th Annual Conservation Forum: EcoLandscaping, Nov. 2, 9 am to 1 pm, in person in Charlottesville and via on-line screening. Learn how to unlove your lawn, leave your leaves, rewild, and much more from three of Virginiaโ€™s leading environmentally-minded horticulturalists. Register here.
  • Sierra Clubโ€™s 2023 Report โ€œThe Dirty Truth about Utilities Climate Pledgesโ€. Dominion Virginiaโ€™s scores (page 13) are Ds.
  • What recent sitings of manatees in the Chesapeake Bay could be telling us about the Bay itself.
  • Grid upgrade and climate resilience funding that Virginia received through the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law and other funding areas from the Inflation Reduction Act.
  • This riparian buffer walk along the Middle River at a Swope farm and learn just how these buffers benefit the land, river, and wildlife.
  • Charlottesville Area Tree Stewardsโ€™ Tree Basics virtual class โ€œSelect, Plant, and Care for Treesโ€, November 2, 7:00 to 9:00 pm. Learn how to select a tree for your property that will have the best chance to survive and flourish in the place that you choose for it. Register here.
  • Join the Blue Ridge Prismโ€™s webinar โ€œRestoring the American Chestnut to the 21st-Century Forest,โ€ November 1, 11:30 am to 1:00 pm. Hear about all the progress thatโ€™s being made; you can enter into a drawing to get two chestnut seedlings to plant on your property. Register here.
  • โ€œThe acclaimed documentary โ€˜King Coalโ€™ [that meditates] โ€ฆ on the legacy of coal mining, exploring its influence on tradition and culture, and examining its impact on health and the environment. The movie, described by critics as beautiful and poetic, serves as an elegy for a way of life that is disappearing, and raises questions about the future of Appalachian mining towns, questions which are left unanswered.โ€

Why not โ€ฆ

The Climate Action Alliance of the Valley (CAAV) is a non-profit, grassroots group in the Central Shenandoah Valley that educates legislators and the public about the implications of the Earthโ€™s worsening climate crisis.

Virginia Environmental News Roundup for Septemberย 2023, Part II

The Climate Action Alliance of the Valley is pleased to provide Harrisonburgโ€™s The Citizen with a monthly survey of energy and environmental news stories about Virginia.

With their permission, we are re-posting these pieces here after they appear in the Citizen.


The link to this piece as first published byย theย Citizenย isย HERE.

Statewide Environmental News Roundup for September 2023, Part II

Announcement:

Social Event for us Climate Activists
Tuesday, October 24th! 
Pale Fire Brewing, Harrisonburg, 5p-?
Please come! Weโ€™d love to meet you!

Energy

Regulations

โ€œThe State Corporation Commission [SCC] could soon be unable to rule on cases before it for the first time in Virginia history because it has only one judge sitting on the bench. The SCC โ€ฆ regulates public utilities, insurance companies, banks and financial institutionsโ€ฆ. The General Assembly failed again โ€ฆ [during the special session] to fill two vacant seats on the threeโ€‘member panel, and now a former commissioner who has been acting as a substitute judge will have to relinquish that role after her appointment as chair of the Virginia Parole Board by Gov. Glenn Youngkin โ€ฆ.โ€

โ€œRegulators slashed Dominion Energyโ€™s three-year plan to make some of its most outage-prone lines less vulnerable to outagescutting some $351 million from the companyโ€™s request to approve $508 million of work. For customers, it will mean an additional $1.38 on a benchmark 1,000 kilowatt-hour bill, which now stands at $125. If the SCC had approved all of the work, that additional cost would have been $1.88.โ€ โ€œAccording to the [SCC] announcement, Dominion had requested permission to harden 111 main feeders but the SCC only approved 44.โ€ Nonetheless, Dominion is proceeding with a plan to bury power lines in Richmond that have the most outages.

Data Centers, Energy Storage

โ€œThe data center industry contributed $54.2 billion to Virginiaโ€™s gross domestic product from 2017 to 2021, according to a [just-released] PricewaterhouseCoopers studyโ€ฆ. That calculation includes indirect impacts โ€ฆ and induced impactsโ€ฆ. The study โ€ฆ [was] commissioned by the Loudoun County-based Data Center Coalitionโ€ฆ. More than 70% of the worldโ€™s internet traffic comes through Data Center Alley โ€” six square miles in Loudounโ€™s Ashburn areaโ€ฆ. While some communities have referred to data centers as game changers, they also are subject to criticisms for being loud, unsightly and large consumers of electricity.โ€

 โ€œData centers, some of the biggest electricity users of all, have signed agreements with Dominion Energy showing they expect to use the equivalent of 35% of the record flow of electricity the utility saw during last yearโ€™s Christmas freezeโ€ฆ. Dominion disclosed the agreements in a few pages of a 221-page โ€ฆ [SCC] filing. The utility took the unusual step of detailing customer agreements about planned data centers โ€” the facilities that house equipment to store and move data, power apps and provide access to computer networks โ€” in response to challenges to its long-term forecasts of electricity demand. That growth, which Dominion said would triple from recent years to hit 5% a year over the next 15 to 25 years, could mean an increase in the utilityโ€™s carbon emissions.โ€

โ€œAs data center developer interest spreads across the stateCaroline County is yet another community in the Fredericksburg region preparing for and dealing with proposals involving the technology that powers cloud computing. Proposals on data centers have popped up in Spotsylvania, Stafford, King George, Louisa and Fauquier counties. Caroline also has drawn interest from data center developers, and the county has proposed changes to its comprehensive plan in order to handle data centers.โ€ โ€œConcerns โ€ฆ [have surfaced] about Caroline [County] water plans {and} regional data centers.โ€ โ€œCaroline County is in the process of applying for a Virginia Water Protection permit from the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality [DEQ]โ€ฆ. โ€œ[I]tโ€™s the anticipation of โ€œmultiple industrial facilities that will rapidly increase water demand in the county,โ€ according to documents filed with the application. A blogger noted that one aspect of the countyโ€™s process for accessing water is controversial because Virginia is a โ€œriparian rightsโ€ state and because of its eminent domain law (Section 11 of Article 1).

โ€œCulpeper Town Council โ€ฆ approved a rezoning for the development of its first proposed data center campus, slated for construction on 116 acres next to the Culpeper National Cemetery annexโ€ฆ. The two parcels, in proximity to the town electric plant and a housing development, were rezoned from residential to industrialโ€ฆ. The town in 2022 created a technology zone on its eastern edge to incentivize the data center use.โ€

To the southeast, a โ€œ1,200-acre data center park [is being] eyed in Hanover County.โ€ The developer filed โ€œa zoning request last week to create a shovel-ready development site for a future data center parkโ€ฆ. If the zoning request is approvedโ€ฆ, [the developer] โ€ฆ plans to spend more than $50 million to create the infrastructure needed for data centers to be built on the siteโ€ฆ.โ€

โ€œDominion Energy said โ€ฆ it has proposed to build a pilot project in Virginia to test two new energy storage technologies which could discharge power for a longer time than traditional batteries. Battery storage projects are critical for the transition towards clean energyโ€ฆ. Dominion said the proposed โ€ฆ storage project โ€ฆ would test โ€ฆ iron-air batteries โ€ฆ and zinc-hybrid batteriesโ€ฆโ€ Dominion said it โ€œwill test [the] two new technologies as potential alternatives to traditional lithium-ion batteries, both of which could offer strengthened safety features for battery storage.โ€ Dominion has asked the SCC to approve these and other battery storage projects.

Renewable Energy and Nuclear Power

โ€œA more-than $500 million redevelopment project is transforming the former Lamberts Point Docks into a hub for offshore wind, shipbuilding and ship repairโ€ฆ. John Larson with Dominion Energy said the wind farm would generate enough energy to power 25% of the utilityโ€™s residential customers in the state. Additionally, more offshore wind sites would be opening up near Dominionโ€™s project soon.โ€ โ€œDominion Energy wants to pay Virginia Beach $19 million for roughly 4 miles of city easements to transmit energy from its offshore wind project. The power company has also agreed to provide $1.14 million to replace trees that will be razed to make room for the transmission lines and power polesโ€ฆ. The Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind farm will be 27 miles off the coast of Virginia Beach and will include 176 wind turbines. It will generate energy to power up to 660,000 homes, according to Dominion. Offshore construction is scheduled to begin next year.โ€ โ€œThe federal Bureau of Ocean Energy Management [BOEM] announced it has completed its environmental assessment of the project, โ€ฆ a little more than two years after the review began. The nearly 700-page report, โ€ฆ to be published September 29 in the Federal Register, starts the clock ticking on a minimum 30-day waiting period before the BOEM issues its final decision on whether to approve the project.โ€

Late last year โ€œDominion Energy โ€ฆ rolled out new fees and requirements for solar installers to connect to the utilityโ€™s grid, but the changes were never approved by state regulatorsโ€ฆ. [Dominion wanted] โ€œto [require] โ€ฆ rooftop installations โ€ฆ [to pay] astronomical grid interconnection fees that [were] stifling the industryโ€™s gains across an expansive swath of Virginiaโ€ฆ. [Solar installers] โ€ฆ across Dominionโ€™s service territory were โ€ฆ reassessing projects they had paused after the investor-owned utility rolled out new and expensive interconnection parameters last December for non-residential, net-metered solar projects. Dominionโ€™s surprise rules โ€” announced more than two years after a major Virginia law bolstered solar โ€” could have boosted the price tag of each school project by at least $1 million โ€ฆ [one installer] estimatedโ€ฆ. Regulators had not vetted the new requirements, which spelled out how solar companies would โ€ฆ pay to upgrade substations, cables and other hardware, as well as cover the cost of a series of studies to guarantee the new projects met safety and reliability requirements. Also, solar array recipients would be required to pay a monthly fee to Dominion to cover maintenance. [T]he utility wanted solar customers to sign what it called a โ€œsmall generator interconnection agreementโ€ so it was clear they would be the ones held liable if their array caused a grid failure.โ€ On behalf of Virginia installers, the Virginia Distributed Solar Alliance requested injunctive relief against Dominion. The SCC acted quickly in Case No. PUR-2023-00097, granting the request from the solar industry to block Dominion from implementing certain technology requirements while the interconnection regulations are under review. The SCC now has pending a review of regulations governing the interconnection of small electric generators and storage resources. This review is pursuant to its May 2 order.

โ€œThe LENOWISCO [acronym for Lee, Wise and Scott counties and the independent city of Norton] Planning Commission is deep into the research phase investigating the possibility of Southwest Virginia becoming the home of one โ€“ or several โ€“ small modular nuclear reactors [SNR], a venture catalyzed by the governorโ€™s energy planโ€ฆ. In particular, he wants Virginia to invest in small modular reactors or SMRs โ€“ in theory, less cost-prohibitive than larger nuclear power plants. The Federal Nuclear Regulatory Commission approved a design for SMRs in the U.S. in Januaryโ€ฆ. In a study funded by the Virginia Department of Energy and GO Virginia Region One, [the company selected to conduct it] assessed the feasibility of seven sites in Southwest Virginiaโ€ฆ. All seven ended up being viableโ€ฆ. The commission has started a supply chain study and is about to dive into a public outreach period to gather area residentsโ€™ feedback about the sites.โ€ฆ [The study spokesperson] anticipates the commission will be finished with both tasks before the end of the yearโ€ฆ. In terms of economic benefit, itโ€™s not so much about the number of jobs the SMRs will provide as it is about the tax base they will supply, according to [the spokesperson] โ€ฆ. Through the Regional Industrial Facilities Authority, LENOWISCO localities can distribute the tax revenue through revenue sharing.โ€

Transportation

โ€œPreliminary work is set to begin this fall on a $2.3 billion rail bridge over the Potomac River โ€” a milestone in Virginiaโ€™s ambitious plan that would expand East Coast commuter and passenger train capacity over the next decade. Virginia Passenger Rail Authority officials โ€ฆ warned of delays if funding isnโ€™t secured in the coming months to close a $729 million budget gap in the stateโ€™s rail program.โ€ Virginiaโ€™s senators โ€œannounced $100 million in federal funds โ€ฆ for the Virginia Passenger Rail Authority to build a rail bridge to ease congestion along a busy stretch of railway in Fairfax County. The money will [fund a] project [that] will expand service capacity and help thwart delays. CSX, Amtrak and VRE use the tracks, and construction is set to take place between 2024 and 2026. โ€œ

Fossil Fuels

โ€œEarlier this month, Virginiaโ€™s Air Board received a report on a โ€œcontroversial permitโ€ for Dominion Energyโ€™s proposed Chesterfield Reliability Center, a 1,000-megawatt power plant that would be used as means of generating electricity in cases of extreme weather. State law defines the project as โ€œcontroversial,โ€ requiring a public hearing and other criteria, because it is a new fossil-fuel generating facility with a capacity of 500 megawatts or moreโ€ฆ. Climate activist groups Third Act and Chesapeake Climate Action Network say the project is more than just controversial by state lawโ€ฆ. [A] Chesterfield County resident with Third Act said because the plant would be built adjacent to the Chesterfield Power Station by the James River, residents in the area will suffer from increased pollutants. โ€˜The neighborhood nearby has suffered with 80 years of coal plant emissions, and they deserve a breakโ€™โ€ฆ.โ€ Dominion Energy provided โ€œEarly details about the pollution impact of a proposed power plant in Eastern Chesterfield County โ€ฆ to the Virginia Air Pollution Control Board โ€ฆ [that heard a presentation] by officials from the Virginia โ€ฆ [DEQ]. The plant has been labeled controversial by state regulators, drawing community pushback. Dominion Energy says itโ€™s needed to keep pace with increasing electrical demand.โ€

โ€œSeveral environmental and civic groups are calling for a natural gas giant and federal regulators to rethink a project that could increase air pollution near one of southeast Virginiaโ€™s most vulnerable communitiesโ€ฆ. The firm behind the contentious Keystone Pipeline โ€ฆ wants to upgrade a compressor station near Petersburgโ€ฆ. The work would remove controls that currently limit the horsepower of existing equipment. โ€ฆ[T]he company also proposes doubling the diameter of nearly 50 miles of existing pipeline through Sussex, Surry, Southampton and Isle of Wight counties as well as the cities of Suffolk and Chesapeake. The expansion and modifications along the Columbia Gas Transmission line have generated nowhere near the amount of outcry as the Mountain Valley Pipeline [MVP] in the western part of the state. But both battles have raised environmental justice concerns over their potential impacts to nearby communities.โ€

โ€œAfter case dismissals, work on โ€ฆ [the MVP in Virginia] resumed [even though the] Pipeline safety administration [PHMSA] call[ed] for further assessment of pipeline conditions following construction delaysโ€ and โ€œadditional inspections of the steel pipe before it is buried, although there has been no final action on a proposed safety order issued Aug. 11โ€ฆ. [C]ritics worry that while negotiations continue, sections of the 42-inch diameter pipe โ€“ which may have been compromised by exposure to the elements since 2017 โ€“ are being placed in the ground as the company rushes to complete construction by the end of the year. In an Aug. 18 letter to PHMSA, about a dozen organizations opposed to the pipeline asked the administration to work with other federal agencies and order that work be stopped until safety conditions are implementedโ€ฆ. [Meanwhile,] โ€œA major leak at a Pennsylvania natural gas storage facility operated by the same company that is leading construction of the โ€ฆ [MVP] was caused by corrosion of a well joint.โ€

In late August, โ€œopponents of the โ€ฆ MVP โ€ฆ protested construction work in Montgomery Countyโ€ฆ. One protestor locked herself to construction equipmentโ€ฆ.โ€ Subsequently, โ€œTwo [more] opponents โ€ฆ chained themselves to heavy equipment at a work siteโ€ฆ. Activists are trying to delay construction of the natural gas pipeline, which they say causes environmental harm and will contribute to climate change. Since construction resumed earlier this summer, at least five people have been arrested.โ€ MVP โ€œis suing more than 40 people and two organizations that it says are unlawfully interfering with its efforts to complete a natural gas pipeline amid growing unrest. The company is asking a judge to issue an injunction that would prevent opponents from entering construction areas, where they have temporarily delayed work at least a dozen times since July 5.โ€ A judge issued โ€œtemporary injunctions against 6 pipeline protestors, but questions [the MVPโ€™s] broader request.โ€

Climate and Environment

Chesapeake Bay, Air, and Water

โ€œRecently, Virginiaโ€™s Coastal Zone Management (CZM) program was highlighted by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) for its $2.8 million investment in almost 100 ecotourism planning and infrastructure projects over the years, with a near 12x return on investment. CZM supports ecotourism initiatives in Virginiaโ€™s rural coastal communities. Learn more about CZMโ€™s success from NOAAโ€™s program highlight.โ€ โ€“ Sept 21, 2023 DEQ newsletter

โ€œPublic Works departments in Harrisonburg and Waynesboro are currently accepting comments related to their Chesapeake Bay Total Maximum Daily Load action plans which serve as a roadmap for reducing pollutants in local waterways before they reach the coastโ€ฆ.  The deadline for comments is Oct. 5. Comments can be submitted in writing to Harrisonburg Environmental and Sustainability Manager Keith Thomas at stormwater@harrisonburgva.gov or by mail to 320 E. Mosby Road, Harrisonburg, Va. 22801.โ€

โ€œEarlier this summer, wildfire smoke lowered air quality in the Eastern U.S. to its worst levels on record. While the smoke has mostly cleared in Virginia since July, scientists are sounding the alarm that โ€” with climate change heating up the world and creating drier conditions โ€” smoky summers will grow increasingly common.โ€

The EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency) awarded โ€œ$4,352,000 for the Virginia โ€ฆ [DEQ]โ€™s Virginia Clean Water Revolving Loan Fund. The funding โ€ฆ will make it possible for VDEQ to offer low-interest loans to local governments โ€ฆ to support efforts to address emerging contaminants that pollute the clean water supply in Virginia. The funding is awarded โ€ฆ [by the EPAโ€™s] Capitalization Grants for Clean Water State Revolving Fund.โ€

Drought and Flooding

โ€œA drought is worsening in parts of the [DC/VA/MD] region. The hardest-hit areas are mostly west of Fairfax and central Montgomery (Md.) counties. The lack of rain has caused crops to wither and prompted concerns about water levels on the Potomac River. Foliage concerns: Itโ€™s especially dry near the Blue Ridge Mountains and Shenandoah Valley, which could mute fall colorsโ€ In late August, the DEQ โ€œissued a drought warning for the counties of Frederick, Clarke, Shenandoah, Warren, Page, Rockingham and Augustaโ€ฆ.โ€

โ€œThe Commonwealth has been awarded $20,053,105 in disaster relief funding from the Federal Emergency Management Agency [FEMA]. The funding provides relief to localities affected by the February 2021 severe winter storm and the impacts of the COVID-19 global pandemic. Administered by the Virginia Department of Emergency Management on behalf of FEMA, the funding is โ€ฆ 90 percent from federal funds and 10 percent state funds.โ€

โ€œOver the past two years, two major deluges in the towns of Hurley and Whitewood in Southwest Virginia have caused catastrophic flooding that left dozens of homes destroyed and one woman dead.

But as the communities have struggled to rebuild, federal relief has been limited. In response, state legislators have dipped into state funds earmarked for other purposes to help with recovery. The main source of that funding is the stateโ€™s proceeds from Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative [RGGI] auctions, which Virginia law dictates must go to flood preparedness and energy efficiency programs. The diversion of nearly $30 million of those funds to post-disaster relief has put a spotlight on Virginiaโ€™s lack of a system to assist individuals recovering from storm damageโ€ฆ. [The] state coordinator at the Virginia Department of Emergency Management โ€ฆ said while the reallocation of RGGI revenues is a way to fill a gap for people impacted by the storms, there is a desire among policymakers for a dedicated state program that could provide individual assistance without waiting on the lengthy budget amendment processโ€ฆ. But with Gov. Glenn Youngkin moving to pull Virginia out of RGGI, that source of funding may soon disappear. And emergency planners say they are seeing increased demand for storm response and recovery.โ€

โ€œTwo major funding opportunities are available to increase flood resilience in the Commonwealth. A total of $103 million is available for advance projects to improve resilience to flooding through the Resilient Virginia Revolving Fund and the Virginia Community Flood Preparedness Fundโ€ฆ. The Resilient Virginia Revolving Fund offers $18.5 million in grants and loansโ€ฆ. The Community Flood Preparedness Fund offers $85 million in grants and loans. Established in 2020 and now in its fourth round โ€ฆ [it] empowers localities to increase capacity for flood resilience and execution of flood protection projects. It supports the implementation of the Commonwealth Resilience Planning Principles detailed in Virginiaโ€™s Coastal Resilience Master Planning Framework.โ€

Wildlife

โ€œAs critical pollinator populations decline, cities and campuses find ways to encourage bees, butterflies and bats. Cities and college campuses across the region have been certified as โ€˜bee-friendly.โ€™ Their efforts include reducing the use of pesticides, allowing native species to thrive, and educating residents and students about how best to help pollinators.โ€ Numerous Virginia cities, towns, and universities are part of โ€œBee City USA.โ€ Emory and Henry College โ€œpartnered with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the Canaan Valley Institute to convert 2 acres into a pollinator meadow.โ€ โ€œMore than $2 million worth of honey is produced in Virginia annually [but a] โ€œVirginia Tech ecology expert [advised] โ€˜Bees do more than just give us honeyโ€™โ€ฆ. Honey is also used for medicinal purposes due to its antimicrobial propertiesโ€ฆ. Along with providing food for surrounding wildlife, honeybee pollination boosts crop production โ€ฆ [and] about a third of the food eaten by Americans comes from crops pollinated by honeybees, according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.โ€

Opinions

  • Authors provided their views on Virginiaโ€™s withdrawal from RGGI. Data on Virginiaโ€™s RGGI auction proceeds areย here.
    • A Virginia delegate argued: โ€œRegional Greenhouse Gas Initiative: Democratsโ€™ misguided, expensive approach to energy production.โ€ โ€“ The Hill
    • An editorial board in Tidewater noted: โ€œThereโ€™s no plan to offset lost RGGI revenue used for flood projects.โ€ โ€“ The Virginian-Pilot
  • Authors also offered their views on large solar projects.
    • A former Trump Administration Interior Department official and current โ€œvice chairman of the Northern Virginia Soil and Water Conservation Districtโ€ attacks big data center companies not for their energy demand, but for anything they do to meet that demand with solar, asking โ€œIs Amazon polluting the Chesapeake Bay?โ€ โ€“ The Richmond Times-Dispatch
    • A Richmond resident penned a response, asserting that โ€œSolar energy has its benefits, too.โ€ โ€“ The Richmond Times-Dispatch
  • A Central Valley farmer and blogger wrote โ€œUtility-scale solar is coming to a farm near you. I support big solar, but it must be done right.โ€ โ€“ The Virginia Mercury
  • A Norfolk City Council member believes โ€œVirginiaโ€™s climate action is on the ballot this fall.โ€ โ€“ The Virginian-Pilot
  • A Virginia energy blogger sees โ€œA bright spot at the intersection of farming, electric vehicles and solar energyโ€, [noting that] Solar is a better deal than corn for the community, since it provides tax revenue, diversifies the local economy and conserves water.โ€ โ€“ The Virginia Mercury
  • A Frederick County resident believes โ€œRenewable energy offers a bright future.โ€ โ€“ The Winchester Star

Check out โ€ฆ

  • NPRโ€™s week-long stories and conversations about the search for climate solutions that you can listen to on WMRA. โ€œThis isnโ€™t just about โ€œcoveringโ€ the climate โ€” itโ€™s meant to remind everyone that you can always do something.โ€ See highlights of specific stories at this link.
  • Blue Ridge Prismโ€™s Three Fall Workshops to build your fundamental knowledge of invasive plants!
    • October 20 workshop, in-person hands-on training in identification and management techniques at McIntire Park Charlottesville, 10 am โ€“ 1 pm, cost $25. Register here.
    • October 24 virtual session will provide an introduction to invasive plants and focus on how to identify them in the autumn and winter, 1 to 3 pm, cost $10. Register here.
    • October 26 virtual session will cover control methods and provide tips on how best to manage these invasive plants during the fall/winter seasons, 1 to 3 pm, Cost $10. Register here.
  • UVAโ€™s Lifelong Learning Institute and Environmental Instituteโ€™s online discussion on the seeming rise of extreme weather events and a planet living with harsh new environmental challenges by a panel of UVA experts, October 11, 2023, 2 โ€“ 3 pm. Register here.
  • Wild Virginiaโ€™s webinar, โ€œRaising Endangered Birds for Success,โ€ and learn about โ€œbird behavior, breeding endangered species, and the release of these beautiful animals into the wildโ€, October 3, 6:30 pm. Register here.
  • This great resource from Advanced Energy United: Making the Most of the Federal Home Energy Rebates,  โ€œMaking the Most of the Federal Home Energy Rebates.โ€ This comprehensive guide focuses on the twin Department of Energy rebate programs, HOMES and HEEHRA, which offer an exceptional opportunity to catalyze the market for residential efficiency, electrification, and distributed energy resources. Created with policymakers in mind, it offers a roadmap to making the most out of the $8.6 billion available for states. Download the toolkit here.โ€
  • Charlottesville Area Tree Stewardsโ€™ (CATS) webinar, โ€œTree Identification by Season: Fallโ€, October 17, 7 pm. Explore the plant pigments that exhibit fall colors and see if they can aid in identification of trees. Register here.
  • UVA Environmental Instituteโ€™s talk, โ€œExtreme Weather Events: A Changing Environment โ€œ, October 11, 2-3 pm. Register here.
  • How โ€œEnergy-Efficiency Programs Aid Virginians With High Utility Costs.โ€ One program is available to residents of the Northern and Central Valley. Apply here.
  • This video about Why Autumn is an Important Season for Gardening.

Why not โ€ฆ

  • View the Dark Skies at Ivy Creek, part of Ivy Creek Foundationโ€™s โ€œThird Friday Under the Starsโ€ series, 8 to 10 pm on October 20, November 17, and December 15, 2023? Details here.
  • Go to the McCormick Observatory Public Night, October 6, 2023 9 pm to 10 pm, 600 McCormick Rd, Charlottesville, VA 22904? Details here.
  • Attend the Chesapeake Bay Foundationโ€™s Defending Virginiaโ€™s Wetlands webinar, Oct. 3, 6:30โ€“8:00 pm? Learn โ€œhow valuable wetlands are for our people, our economy, and our environmentโ€ and how they โ€œare now at risk โ€ฆ in light of the recent Sackett v. EPA Supreme Court decision. Register here.
  • Respond to theย Virginia Department of Forestryโ€™s (DOF) request to Virginians to help collect acorns and nuts and drop them off to be planted at its Augusta Nursery? Through statewide collection efforts, DOF nurseries plant more trees, of more species, from varied genetics.ย Acorns may be dropped off at any DOF office location by Oct. 16. For more information about acorn collection, contact the Augusta Nursery at (540) 363-7000. DOF needs these species this year:
    • Black Oak, Chestnut Oak, White Oak, Northern Red Oak, Southern Red Oak, Pin Oak, Shumard Oak, Swamp Chestnut Oak, Swamp White Oak, Water Oak, Willow Oak, Black Chestnut & Chinese Chestnut
  • Join the webinar, โ€œStopping Utilities From Using Our Money Against Usโ€, October 5, 7pm? Register here. A panel discussion will describe recently passed laws to stop utilities from using ratepayer funds for lobbying, political campaign donations, and other inappropriate uses. Learn how to launch a similar effort in Virginia. Dominion Energy is one of the utilities whose ratepayers help pay for their political campaign donations.
  • Learn about Southeastern Grasslands? Did you know that โ€œThere are more types of grasslands in the Southeast than the entirety of the Great Plains and Midwestern prairies?โ€

The Climate Action Alliance of the Valley (CAAV) is a non-profit, grassroots group in the Central Shenandoah Valley that educates legislators and the public about the implications of the Earthโ€™s worsening climate crisis.

2023 Virginia General Assembly Candidates Questionnaire

The Climate Action Alliance of the Valley (CAAV) is a volunteer, grassroots nonprofit organization, headquartered in Harrisonburg, with over 540 members.

CAAVโ€™s mission is to limit the impact of humans on Earthโ€™s climate, thereby providing for the common good by protecting the future of Earth and its inhabitants. CAAVโ€™s goal is to have legislators who are familiar with the best scientific understanding of climate change so that they will consider the climatic implications, including risks, of any decisions they make. By so doing we hope to bring about the systemic change required to protect Earthโ€™s climate and its associated benefits for current and future generations.


CAAV asked the candidates for General Assembly seats representing the districts in the CAAV area in the November 2023 electionย to complete a questionnaire regarding their positions on pressing climate and energy issues.

As of the September 30, 2023, completion request date, we’ve heard from the candidates below. Click on their name to find their responses.

Randall Wolf, House of Delegates, District 36

Kathy Beery, Senate, District 2

Esther Nizer, House of Delegates, District 34

Thanks to these candidates for taking the time to let us know their positions on these issues!

Esther Nizer

2023 VA General Assembly Candidates Questionnaire from Climate Action Alliance of the Valley

Name: ย Esther Nizer

Office you are seeking: ย House of Delegates, District 34

Find the pdf version of the questionnaire with Esther Nizer’s responses HERE.

1. The Shenandoah Valley is experiencing more frequent and more severe extreme weather events as a likely result of climate change, including heat waves and unhealthy levels of air pollution, and we are at increased risk of flooding events. These events negatively affect all of us, but disproportionately impact historically disadvantaged and low-income communities. These communities suffer the negative impacts of local industry, such as pollution, but too often do not receive any of the benefits of the wealth generated by these industries. Legislation has been introduced in other states to address the cumulative impacts of pollution in permitting decisions and expand the types of legal actions available to individuals whose health and well-being have been impacted by pollution.

What legislation will you introduce or support to address environmental justice concerns?

I would support requiring health impact assessments for projects with potential health implications in historically disadvantaged and low-income communities

Creating legislation that would strengthen community right-to-know laws to ensure that residents are informed about nearby environmental hazards, emissions, and pollutants. Transparency is important and this would allow communities to protect themselves.

2. The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) is a cooperative effort among the states of Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Virginia to cap and reduce CO2 emissions from the power sector. Through July 2023, more than $500 million in RGGI auction proceeds have already been invested in Virginia businesses through energy efficiency, clean and renewable energy, greenhouse gas abatement, and direct bill assistance programs. RGGI is a major tool that can help low-income Virginiaโ€™s reduce their energy bills and stay in their homes. It is also a very effective way to enable communities to improve their flood resilience and preparedness. Currently there is no clear plan for replacing the RGGI funds should Virginia cease its participation in the program.

Will you introduce or support legislation supporting Virginiaโ€™s continued participation in the RGGI coalition?ย  Yes_X_ย  No ___ Please explain your position.

I am most interested in reducing carbon dioxide emissions, which contribute to climate change. Reducing emissions can help improve air quality and public health outcomes. The Shenandoah Valley provides a variety of opportunities for its citizens to be outdoors. It is important that the air they breathe is clean.

If not, will you introduce or support legislation to replace the funding streams that RGGI has provided?ย  Yes ____ No ____ Please explain your position.

3. Will you introduce or support legislation that further restores the authority of the State Corporation Commission to set fair rates and charges for ratepayers? Yes ___ No ___ If yes, please describe the legislation you will introduce or would support. If no, please explain your position.

I would first want to talk to the experts in the field before presenting legislation.
I am most concerned about rates, especially in rural areas where I live. Regulatory oversight can be critical to ensuring that residents have access to essential services. Without this oversight, utility companies may be less inclined to invest in these areas.
I would certainly support legislation that would restore the authority to set fair rates.

4. Beyond the Virginia Clean Economy Act, Virginia has the option of supporting the increased use of renewable energy, principally solar and wind sources, and to increase energy efficiency.

Will you introduce or support legislation that encourages or incentivizes the adoption of more renewable energy and improved energy efficiency? Yes_X_ย  No ___ย  If yes, will you include individual and small scale distributed solar in such legislation?ย  If not, please explain your position.

Absolutely, we must be willing to work with everyone from individual to small scale to handle distribution.

5. The risks and costs of the climate crisis are already being detected and are projected to increase in Virginia. Virginia’s coastal zone is the second most vulnerable region in the U.S.โ€”surpassed only by the area surrounding New Orleansโ€”to the predicted impacts of climate change, including sea level rise. Additional impacts across all of Virginia will include increasing incidents of extreme heat, drought, flooding, extreme weather, and infectious diseases beyond what we have already experienced.

What legislation will you introduce or support to help Virginia mitigate and adapt to climate change impacts? If none, please explain your position.

There are several areas that are of interest to me:
Public transportation especially in rural areas. Possibly using electric vehicles. I would also support investing in walking and biking infrastructure.
Energy efficiency can range from energy-efficient appliances to building codes.

6. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administrationโ€™s Annual CO2 Inventory for the Commonwealth of Virginia, 51% of our carbon emissions are coming from the transportation sector.

What legislation, such as a Low Carbon Fuel Standard, tax incentives for EVs, electric bike incentives, increased availability of light rail passenger service, requirements for more rural transit/microtransit options, will you introduce or support to help reduce carbon emissions from Virginiaโ€™s transportation sector? If none, please explain your position.

Legislation related to funding for rural transit agencies to address transportation in rural areas. Incentives for electric bikes such as rebates or tax credits.
I would welcome a discussion on light rail expansion, especially between small towns.

7. Virginia has some of the weakest campaign finance laws in the country. Will you pledge to support campaign finance reforms to limit the amount any one person or organization can give to a candidate and require more transparency in disclosures? Yes_X_ No___ย ย ย  Please explain your position.

The amount of funds spent on campaigns is out of line. There need to be limits on the amount of money spent. I would support campaign limits of no more than double the salary paid for the position. In the case of the House of Delegates, the limit would not exceed $35,000.

8. Please describe any other actions you would take in the General Assembly to help Virginia reduce its greenhouse gas emissions, support the adoption of renewable energy and increased energy efficiency, and mitigate the impacts of climate change.

One action that I would take would be to have more public education opportunities available to the citizens. Having experts in the area explain the benefits of greenhouse reduction can go a long way in getting people to fully understand the impact of climate change.

Thank you for taking the time to complete this questionnaire.

Appendix

Web-sourced references:

Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative – http://www.rggi.org/

Renewable Energy

  1. http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/states/state_home.cfm/state=VA
  2. http://www.nrdc.org/energy/renewables/virginia.asp
  3. http://www.acore.org/files/pdfs/states/Virginia.pdf
  4. http://www.seia.org/state-solar-policy/virginia-solar

Climate Change Impacts

  1. Coastal – http://www.vims.edu/research/units/programs/icccr/index.php
  2. Multi-sector – http://www.nrdc.org/health/climate/va.asp

Transportation – http://www.afdc.energy.gov/laws/state_summary?state=VA

Kathy Beery

2023 VA General Assembly Candidates Questionnaire from Climate Action Alliance of the Valley

Name: ย Kathy Beery

Office you are seeking: ย Senate, District 2

Find the pdf version of the questionnaire with Kathy Beery’s responses HERE.

1. The Shenandoah Valley is experiencing more frequent and more severe extreme weather events as a likely result of climate change, including heat waves and unhealthy levels of air pollution, and we are at increased risk of flooding events. These events negatively affect all of us, but disproportionately impact historically disadvantaged and low-income communities. These communities suffer the negative impacts of local industry, such as pollution, but too often do not receive any of the benefits of the wealth generated by these industries. Legislation has been introduced in other states to address the cumulative impacts of pollution in permitting decisions and expand the types of legal actions available to individuals whose health and well-being have been impacted by pollution.

What legislation will you introduce or support to address environmental justice concerns?

In 2020, the state established a Council on Environmental Justice and passed legislation (HB704/SB406). The last minutes online are from January 2023 and the council lacked a quorum to meet. Before adding new legislation into the mix, I want to know what has been done, how it has worked, and what needs to be done differently to make effective policies in this area. It certainly looks like this has been a political football and legislation has been passed on strict party lines. So, priority one is depoliticizing this issue. Without a bipartisan coalition to promote environmental justice policies, not much is going to happen. I think this can be done when we remember that class โ€“ which cuts across racial and ethnic identity groups โ€“ is a significant factor in environmental injustice.

2. The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) is a cooperative effort among the states of Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Virginia to cap and reduce CO2 emissions from the power sector. Through July 2023, more than $500 million in RGGI auction proceeds have already been invested in Virginia businesses through energy efficiency, clean and renewable energy, greenhouse gas abatement, and direct bill assistance programs. RGGI is a major tool that can help low-income Virginiaโ€™s reduce their energy bills and stay in their homes. It is also a very effective way to enable communities to improve their flood resilience and preparedness. Currently there is no clear plan for replacing the RGGI funds should Virginia cease its participation in the program.

Will you introduce or support legislation supporting Virginiaโ€™s continued participation in the RGGI coalition?ย  Yes_X_ย  No ___ Please explain your position.

If not, will you introduce or support legislation to replace the funding streams that RGGI has provided?ย  Yes ____ No ____ Please explain your position.

Yes, of course. We need to rejoin RGGI.

3. Will you introduce or support legislation that further restores the authority of the State Corporation Commission to set fair rates and charges for ratepayers? Yes __X_ No ___ If yes, please describe the legislation you will introduce or would support. If no, please explain your position.

Yes, and beyond that we need to prohibit publicly regulated utilities from donating to political campaigns or creating PACs to support political candidates.

4. Beyond the Virginia Clean Economy Act, Virginia has the option of supporting the increased use of renewable energy, principally solar and wind sources, and to increase energy efficiency.

Will you introduce or support legislation that encourages or incentivizes the adoption of more renewable energy and improved energy efficiency? Yes_X_ย  No ___ย  If yes, will you include individual and small scale distributed solar in such legislation?ย  If not, please explain your position.

We are at a point of transition โ€“ not only in the way we produce energy but in the way it is distributed. It is a mistake to focus only on the production, not the distribution methods. The centralization of production is about monetizing energy for the bene๏ฌt of a corporation. If that system is replaced with distributed production, we need to be sure that the poor who are unable to invest in producing their own energy are not left depending on a centralized system with skyrocketing rates. So, yes, I support distributing production and I want to make sure we donโ€™t cause harm to the most vulnerable as we make that change. This is not going to be easy in the current system where publicly regulated utilities can buy elected leaders with unlimited campaign donations. See above.

5. The risks and costs of the climate crisis are already being detected and are projected to increase in Virginia. Virginia’s coastal zone is the second most vulnerable region in the U.S.โ€”surpassed only by the area surrounding New Orleansโ€”to the predicted impacts of climate change, including sea level rise. Additional impacts across all of Virginia will include increasing incidents of extreme heat, drought, flooding, extreme weather, and infectious diseases beyond what we have already experienced.

What legislation will you introduce or support to help Virginia mitigate and adapt to climate change impacts? If none, please explain your position.

I will ๏ฌrst research what others have been doing and see who can help create a coalition for this.

The other side of this equation is preparing for climate refugees from coastal areas who will be moving to Senate District 2. This requires that we prepare our economy and our infrastructure to absorb population increases in the next 20 years. Part of that involves growing industrial hemp and creating related industries to produce hemp products. Hemp also helps mitigate climate change.

6. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administrationโ€™s Annual CO2 Inventory for the Commonwealth of Virginia, 51% of our carbon emissions are coming from the transportation sector.

What legislation, such as a Low Carbon Fuel Standard, tax incentives for EVs, electric bike incentives, increased availability of light rail passenger service, requirements for more rural transit/microtransit options, will you introduce or support to help reduce carbon emissions from Virginiaโ€™s transportation sector? If none, please explain your position.

Again, I will research what is being done and look to build a coalition to achieve these goals.

7. Virginia has some of the weakest campaign finance laws in the country. Will you pledge to support campaign finance reforms to limit the amount any one person or organization can give to a candidate and require more transparency in disclosures? Yes_X_ No___ย ย ย  Please explain your position.

It is embarrassing that a state that claims to be the cradle of democracy in this country has a system that is basically pay-to-play. This is a top priority if we are going to address our most pressing issues.

8. Please describe any other actions you would take in the General Assembly to help Virginia reduce its greenhouse gas emissions, support the adoption of renewable energy and increased energy efficiency, and mitigate the impacts of climate change.

One of the most interesting experiences on the campaign trail has been discovering that the Chambers of Commerce in SD2 are all putting forward policy agendas that prioritize things like a๏ฌ€ordable housing, rural public transportation, and childcare. We have a chance to build a coalition between climate activists and our local business communities to address the need for a 21st-century transportation system that includes mitigating climate change. I look forward to facilitating those conversations and connecting the results to policymaking in Richmond.

Thank you for taking the time to complete this questionnaire.

Appendix

Web-sourced references:

Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative – http://www.rggi.org/

Renewable Energy

  1. http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/states/state_home.cfm/state=VA
  2. http://www.nrdc.org/energy/renewables/virginia.asp
  3. http://www.acore.org/files/pdfs/states/Virginia.pdf
  4. http://www.seia.org/state-solar-policy/virginia-solar

Climate Change Impacts

  1. Coastal – http://www.vims.edu/research/units/programs/icccr/index.php
  2. Multi-sector – http://www.nrdc.org/health/climate/va.asp

Transportation – http://www.afdc.energy.gov/laws/state_summary?state=VA

Randall Wolf

2023 VA General Assembly Candidates Questionnaire from Climate Action Alliance of the Valley

Name: ย Randall Wolf

Office you are seeking: ย House of Delegates, District 36

Find the pdf version of the questionnaire with Randall Wolf’s responses HERE.ย 

1. The Shenandoah Valley is experiencing more frequent and more severe extreme weather events as a likely result of climate change, including heat waves and unhealthy levels of air pollution, and we are at increased risk of flooding events. These events negatively affect all of us, but disproportionately impact historically disadvantaged and low-income communities. These communities suffer the negative impacts of local industry, such as pollution, but too often do not receive any of the benefits of the wealth generated by these industries. Legislation has been introduced in other states to address the cumulative impacts of pollution in permitting decisions and expand the types of legal actions available to individuals whose health and well-being have been impacted by pollution.

What legislation will you introduce or support to address environmental justice concerns?

Legislation will need to address so many items regarding our changing weather and the impacts on people who live, work, and play in Virginia. I will assure that these programs will protect historically disadvantaged groups and low income communities and the people who live there. This may even be an opportunity to address past decisions that negatively impacted these groups.

I believe that renewable energy is critical to address this. I would reengage with RGGI.

We have to review flood zones and how the insurance industry serves people who may be affected by dramatic weather events in the future. We also need to look at wildfire zones where building would be prevent just as we do with flooding.

2. The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) is a cooperative effort among the states of Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Virginia to cap and reduce CO2 emissions from the power sector. Through July 2023, more than $500 million in RGGI auction proceeds have already been invested in Virginia businesses through energy efficiency, clean and renewable energy, greenhouse gas abatement, and direct bill assistance programs. RGGI is a major tool that can help low-income Virginiaโ€™s reduce their energy bills and stay in their homes. It is also a very effective way to enable communities to improve their flood resilience and preparedness. Currently there is no clear plan for replacing the RGGI funds should Virginia cease its participation in the program.

Will you introduce or support legislation supporting Virginiaโ€™s continued participation in the RGGI coalition?ย  Yes_X_ย  No ___ Please explain your position.

Itโ€™s ridiculous that Gov. Youngkin removed us from this important environmental program. I will support legislation to have Virginia return to RGGI and seek bills to provide programs for low and middle income people to gain access and the benefits of low cost renewable energy. We need to address increase flooding and provide security for all communities. In some cases this could be an opportunity to address past actions by Virginia regarding low income and minority communities.

If not, will you introduce or support legislation to replace the funding streams that RGGI has provided?ย  Yes ____ No ____ Please explain your position.

3. Will you introduce or support legislation that further restores the authority of the State Corporation Commission to set fair rates and charges for ratepayers? Yes __X_ No ___ If yes, please describe the legislation you will introduce or would support. If no, please explain your position.

Iโ€™m sorry, but this legislation would need to be worked out with experts and stakeholders, Iโ€™m not in a position to suggest wording for this legislation now.

4. Beyond the Virginia Clean Economy Act, Virginia has the option of supporting the increased use of renewable energy, principally solar and wind sources, and to increase energy efficiency.

Will you introduce or support legislation that encourages or incentivizes the adoption of more renewable energy and improved energy efficiency? Yes_X_ย  No ___ย  If yes, will you include individual and small scale distributed solar in such legislation?ย  If not, please explain your position.

I would propose legislation that requires any new building projects in Virginia that use taxpayer funds, grants or bonds to have a minimum of 50 percent of their electricity come from renewable energy. Virginia needs to lead and set the example for how to incorporate renewable energy in building projects.

5. The risks and costs of the climate crisis are already being detected and are projected to increase in Virginia. Virginia’s coastal zone is the second most vulnerable region in the U.S.โ€”surpassed only by the area surrounding New Orleansโ€”to the predicted impacts of climate change, including sea level rise. Additional impacts across all of Virginia will include increasing incidents of extreme heat, drought, flooding, extreme weather, and infectious diseases beyond what we have already experienced.

What legislation will you introduce or support to help Virginia mitigate and adapt to climate change impacts? If none, please explain your position.

I do not have specific legislation.

6. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administrationโ€™s Annual CO2 Inventory for the Commonwealth of Virginia, 51% of our carbon emissions are coming from the transportation sector.

What legislation, such as a Low Carbon Fuel Standard, tax incentives for EVs, electric bike incentives, increased availability of light rail passenger service, requirements for more rural transit/microtransit options, will you introduce or support to help reduce carbon emissions from Virginiaโ€™s transportation sector? If none, please explain your position.

I strongly support EVโ€™s and alternative transportation for human locomotion. I would support tax refunds for eBikes, EVโ€™s and other incentives for people who walk or use public transportation. I would also push VDOT to increase building public infrastructure for people who walk or bike at transportation, not just recreation.

7. Virginia has some of the weakest campaign finance laws in the country. Will you pledge to support campaign finance reforms to limit the amount any one person or organization can give to a candidate and require more transparency in disclosures? Yes_X_ No___ย ย ย  Please explain your position.

I would like to see the current federal laws be put in place for Virginia.

8. Please describe any other actions you would take in the General Assembly to help Virginia reduce its greenhouse gas emissions, support the adoption of renewable energy and increased energy efficiency, and mitigate the impacts of climate change.

Iโ€™ve been a board member of the Shenandoah Valley Bicycle Coalition and a advocate for biking and walking for decades. Currently Iโ€™m part of the organizing team for a walk bike summit in Staunton, Waynesboro, and Augusta County. Iโ€™m also active with a local group of family farmers who have a proposal for a 700 acre solar project that is being blocked in Augusta County. These issues are important to me and I will see as many avenues to promote reducing greenhouse gases and increasing the health of the people of Virginia.

Thank you for taking the time to complete this questionnaire.

Appendix

Web-sourced references:

Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative – http://www.rggi.org/

Renewable Energy

  1. http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/states/state_home.cfm/state=VA
  2. http://www.nrdc.org/energy/renewables/virginia.asp
  3. http://www.acore.org/files/pdfs/states/Virginia.pdf
  4. http://www.seia.org/state-solar-policy/virginia-solar

Climate Change Impacts

  1. Coastal – http://www.vims.edu/research/units/programs/icccr/index.php
  2. Multi-sector – http://www.nrdc.org/health/climate/va.asp

Transportation – http://www.afdc.energy.gov/laws/state_summary?state=VA

Climate and Energy News Roundup โ€“ October 2023

In the face of climate change, we all have to be optimistic, not because success is guaranteed but because failure is unthinkable. โ€”Christiana Figueres and Tom Rivett-Carnac

Our Climate Crisis

A UN climate report card on progress since the 2015 Paris Agreement says countries are trying, but urgently need to improve their efforts. Many of the worst-case climate change scenarios now look far less likely yet efforts made thus far still arenโ€™t enough to avoid calamity. The report is meant to serve as the foundation for the next round of climate negotiations, known as COP28, that will start in late November in Dubai, in the United Arab Emirates.

Increased global warming will cause 500 million people around the world, particularly in places such as South Asia and the Middle East, to be exposed to life threatening extreme heat for at least a month by 2030โ€”even if they can get out of the sun. This will create a new global wave of disease and death linked to climate change, according to an analysis of climate data and leading scientific studies. Pakistan will be the epicenter of places that bear the brunt of Earthโ€™s heating.

Climate-fueled weather disasters have exponentially increased the cost of the Federal Crop Insurance Program from just under $3 billion in 2002 to just over $19 billion last year. Annual payouts in 2022 were 546% more than they were in 2001. Farmers pay about 40% of the premiums and taxpayers subsidize about 60%. Roughly 80% of crop insurance payments go to the largest 20% of farms that primarily grow one or two carbon intensive crops.

Politics and Policy

Research shows that the World Bank spent billions of dollars backing fossil fuels in 2022 despite repeated promises to refocus on shifting to a low-carbon economy. The money went through a special form of funding known as trade finance, which lacks transparency on funds used for oil and gas development.  Until that is changed, the World Bank cannot claim to be aligned with the Paris climate agreement.

Virginia utility regulators ruled against Dominion Energyโ€™s attempt to saddle rooftop installations with astronomical grid interconnection fees that were stifling the industryโ€™s gains across Virginia. At stake were medium sized 25 Kw to 1 Mw solar installations that use power purchase agreements. These kinds of solar installations have appealed to universities, public schools, hospitals, churches, municipalities and small commercial ventures.

California is suing five oil companies and their trade group, the American Petroleum Institute, over what the state says is a long-standing pattern of deceiving the public over the risks associated with fossil fuel. According to the complaint, this is causing billions of dollars in damage to communities and the environment. The lawsuit claims the oil companies have created a public nuisance, damaged natural resources and state property and have violated California law with false advertising and misleading environmental marketing.

Energy

The great news is that Virginia is meeting short-term carbon-free targets laid out in the sweeping Clean Economy Act of 2020. A big challenge is that new clean energy projects are gummed-up in their regional grid operatorโ€™s transmission interconnection queue, potentially stalling this progress. Off-shore wind is projected to make up a big proportion of new clean energy installations in the coming decades.

Building the worldโ€™s first large-scale green steel plant just moved closer to becoming a reality. H2 Green Steel, the company behind the groundbreaking project in Sweden, recently announced that it has raised the necessary funding to build the plant and begin production in 2025. Clean hydrogen will replace fossil fuels in the steelmaking process. The steelmaking industry is responsible for between 7 and 9% of global carbon emissions.

Dominion Energy is seeking an air quality permit from the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality to build a new natural gas plant that will be a major new source of greenhouse gas emissions. Dominion claims the plant is needed to provide future projected demand for power from data centers and EVs. Environmental groups are sharply criticizing the proposed plant on the grounds that it goes against the goal of the Virginia Clean Economy Act, which requires Dominion to decarbonize its grid by midcentury.

Offshore wind has had a rough summer due to rising interest rates and delays in getting key components. This has led developers to ask for new terms in existing deals. Itโ€™s a messy situation that threatens to undermine the future of offshore wind as a major and affordable source of clean electricity. More positively, rather than backing out of projects, companies are saying they need to renegotiate agreements. While this may mean delays and an increase in costs for consumers, itโ€™s far from a catastrophe.

The European Union is on track to reach the renewable energy goal it set for 2030 three years early according to the 2023 annual report of Solar Power Europe. Solar is on a fast track around the world. In 2022, 45% more solar power capacity was installed than the year before. The positive market developments in the first months of 2023 promise another solar boom year, with expected growth of 43%.

Electric vehicles have heavy batteries that are filled with minerals extracted from around the world. You may have heard that this makes fossil fuel vehicles look good. Global fossil fuel extraction, however, dwarfs mineral mining for clean energy. Fifteen billion tons of coal, oil, and gas were extracted in 2019 compared to seven million tons of minerals that were extracted in 2020 for the entire clean energy economy. Furthermore, unlike fossil fuels, minerals can be reused and recycled.

Climate Justice

Faith leaders joined the demand for climate justice at the Africa Climate Summit in Nairobi hosted by the African Union and the government of Kenya. Activist groups had hoped that the summit would develop a radical vision for Africa, but the final declaration was disappointingly similar to previous climate summits that produced inadequate results. The climate activists then produced their own statement which said the final declaration imposed failed climate policies on the continent and reflected old colonial attitudes.

Kolkata, a city of more than 4.5 million in eastern India, is a microcosm of how global warming unequally affects the urban poor. Since 1950, the cityโ€™s average temperature has risen more than any megacityโ€” by 4.7 degrees Fahrenheit. The heat is expected to keep soaring, along with more intense cyclones, monsoon rainfalls and rampant flooding. Living in densely built neighborhoods with narrow streets and alleys, little or no tree cover, and a paucity of basic services like electricity, the urban poor bear the brunt of these climate changes.

Developing countries are often on the frontlines of the climate crisis yet lack the resources to develop clean energy and to enact climate action plans. At the same time, large banks have been pouring some $3.2 trillion into the fossil fuel industry to expand operations in the global south. They have also loaned and underwritten at least $370 billion in developing countries for the expansion of industrial agriculture, which is a major a contributor to global warming.

Bhutan, a small Buddhist kingdom nestled in the Himalayas between India and China, has 70% forest cover and is carbon neutral. It has environmental commitments to maintain at least 60% forest cover and to remain carbon neutral. Despite its exemplary climate stewardship it faces risks from rising temperatures and melting glaciers. Agriculture employs 43% of the labor force with women making up 53.3% of that total. Given agricultureโ€™s vulnerability to climate change, the country is focusing on training girls in climate literacy.  

Looming over the United Auto Workers strike against Ford, General Motors and Stellantis is concern that many EV battery and assembly plants are being built in the Southโ€”a region long characterized by low wages and hostility to labor unions. Union leaders are concerned that this shift will lower wages and cut out unions from the auto industryโ€™s future.

Climate Action

Over 75,000 climate activists marched in New York City at the start of Climate Week at the UN General Assembly. They demanded that President Joe Biden stop approving new oil and gas projects, phase out current ones and declare a climate emergency. Speaking to a cheering crowd, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez exclaimed, โ€œWe have to send a message that some of us are going to be living on, on this planet 30, 40, 50 years from now. And we will not take no for an answer.โ€

One day after the March to End Fossil Fuels, climate activists blockaded multiple entrances into the Federal Reserve bank in an act of civil disobedience and more than 100 were arrested. They were calling attention to the fact that globally, government subsidies for coal, oil and gas are equivalent to 7% of global GDP and almost double what the world spends on education.

Electric cars are smashing sales records in the U.S. and now exceed 7% of new cars soldโ€”a critical tipping point for mass adoption. It took 10 years to sell the first million fully electric vehicles in our country, two years to reach the second million, and just over a year to reach the third. We should be well on our way to a fourth million by the time the latest quarter’s figures for 2023 are tallied up.

The Harrisonburg City Council unanimously approved supporting the Commercial Property Assessed Clean Energy program that helps businesses in the city adopt renewable energy. Vice mayor Laura Dent was especially enthusiastic because it addresses the missing business sector in the cityโ€™s energy efficiency goals for the community.

Action Alerts

NPR is dedicating an entire week to stories and conversations about the search for climate solutions. Reporting teams across the NPR Network have been scouring the world for solutions to climate change. They’re sharing what they found this week. This isn’t just about “covering” the climate โ€” it’s meant to remind everyone that you can always do something. See highlights of specific stories at this link.

Climate Activist Social on Tuesday, October 24, 5pm โ€“ until, at Pale Fire Brewing Co., 217 S Liberty St #105, Harrisonburg, VA. Calling all Rocktown climate advocates, seasoned or interested! Come have a drink (or not) with us. Let’s have a meeting without an agenda. This social event is hosted by the Climate Action Alliance of the Valley. There will be a table for things to sign or pick up, but really, this is a social time. Come, invite your friends and RSVP here!

Earl Zimmerman
CAAV Steering Committee

Request for Proposals: Energy Efficiency Outreach Grants

Climate Action Alliance of the Valley (CAAV), in partnership with Community Housing Partners (CHP) Energy Solutions, seeks project proposals from community organizations in the Central Shenandoah Valley, including the cities of Harrisonburg, Waynesboro, and Staunton, and Rockingham, Augusta, Page, Shenandoah, and Highland counties. CAAV will award grants of up to $15,000 for projects to promote and facilitate applications to existing no-cost-to-client weatherization and energy efficiency opportunities offered through CHP to qualifying area residents. Promotion methods may vary based on the organizational proposal, but could include attending community events, door-to-door canvassing, or case management and applicant follow-up. Organizations who serve persons who likely qualify for CHP programs are preferred, including but not limited to organizations who serve low to moderate income households, households with seniors and persons with disabilities, ALICE and energy burdened households, and households in historically marginalized or disadvantaged communities.

Requirements for Proposals

Proposals for the Energy Efficiency Outreach Grant should outline how the organization can connect eligible households with the programs offered through CHP Energy Solutions.

Energy Efficiency Outreach Grants should outline the following:
โ— the populations with which the community organization currently works;
โ— steps the organization would take to promote program awareness and assist applicants
in submitting required documentation through the CHP application process;
โ— how the funds will specifically enable the organization to do this work;
โ— and the methods for tracking and reporting on outreach efforts, including, for example,
the number of events held or attended to promote the program, number of households
contacted, materials distributed, doors knocked, expenditures, etc.

Proposals can be of varying scopes, and include anything from adding CHPโ€™s programs to an existing lists of resources the organization offers to engaging in a months-long campaign. Some potential proposals:

โ— $1k-$3k for staff/volunteer training to add CHP programs to existing list-promoted services
โ— $3k-$6k for training + short term campaign with events, canvassing, community
outreach, etc
โ— $6k+ for training + dedicated staff time over a period of several months. This could include a case management approach assisting applicants in gathering and submitting required documentation for program approval.

Upon approval for an Energy Efficiency Outreach Grant, CHP and CAAV will provide program marketing materials and training workshops to orient you and your staff to CHPโ€™s programs. Both organizations will consult and collaborate with participating organizations throughout the grant period. CAAV, which received a grant from Clean Virginia, will award a total of $35,000 to local community organizations. CAAV aims to select a cohort of grant recipients that extends outreach to diverse Central Valley populations. Successful grant applicants will submit a report to CAAV outlining its performance results based on criteria in the memorandum of understanding or contract.

Energy Efficiency Programs through CHP Energy Solutions

CHP Energy Solutions is a 501(c)(3) non-profit headquartered in Christiansburg, Virginia. Since 1976, CHP has been creating homes and communities that are healthy, sustainable, and affordable. For the Shenandoah Valley, CHP Energy Solutions is the Virginia Department of Housing and Community Developmentโ€™s (DHCD) designated Weatherization Assistance Program provider. This federally funded program improves the energy efficiency of homes and apartments, lowering energy buren for households while improving health and safety. In addition to the Weatherization Programs, CHP Energy Solutions checks eligible households across a suite of other no-cost programs designed to lower utility bills, improve health and safety, and reduce emissions. The include programs through Dominion Energy, Shenandoah Valley Electric Cooperative (SVEC), Harrisonburg Electric Commission (HEC), and Columbia Gas. Programs are open to qualifying renters and homeowners, including households in site-built, manufactured/mobile homes, and townhomes. If approved, improvements can include installation of insulation, LED bulbs, and dozens of other measures to reduce energy consumption. Depending on the program and availability of funds, additional measures can include heating and cooling system repair or replacement, minor home repair, solar, and more.

For a greater sense of the impact of these programs and what they offer, check out:
โ— Success Stories page on the CHP Energy Solutions website.
โ— Success Story: Ms. Carter’s Home Elkton, VA
โ— WHSV Interview with Everett Brubaker from CHP Energy Solutions
โ— Article in Shenandoah Valley Electric Cooperative (SVEC) Magazine
โ— Conversation with Beth Bland of Valley Program for Aging Services (VPAS) on WSVA
โ— Article on Weatherization work at Mosby Heights Townhomes in Harrisonburg

Grant Timeline

Request for Proposals
– September 18 to October 31

Grant Informational Sessions
– October 18 at 12pm (on Zoom)
– October 19 at 4pm

Final Date for Proposals
– October 31

Announcement of Grant Recipients
– December 4

Grant Implementation by Selected Organizations
– January 2024 – May 2024

For more information, please reach out to:

Andrew Payton (CAAV)
andrewdpayton [at] gmail.com

Everett Brubaker (CHP)
everett.brubaker [at] chpc2.org

Find this proposal as a PDF here: CAAV_CHP Request for Proposals